Recapping Interrobang: From Derailing Conversations to Diversity Hires (Part 2)
Travis: From their point of view.
Tybee: From their point of view, ya.
So a character who’s gimmick is that they are super fat, from a joke vault where EVERYONE is massively obese and so, to them, he is skinny as a twig, but out in the wasteland he’s a big fat guy, THIS is the positive, fat representation that Tybee is proud to have brought to her audience who, you know she doesn’t relate to him, but the fans, ‘from their point of view’, can relate to him so much!
Ah, but you see, parts of Tybee’s team pushed back on this fat guy getting a love interest because ‘no one wanted to see that, because ‘Twig isn’t sexy’.’ But Tybee ‘hated that so much’ and pushed back ‘so hard’ because she knows fat people deserve love too.
If Travis is in the corner, ‘reading Playboy for the articles’, Tybee is sitting in front of a class in the inner city, going, ‘Did you know Shakespeare was the gangster rapper of his day?’
Travis, trying to understand why people had an issue with ‘Twig’ getting a love interest asks, “Did people just not believe its even possible for a fat guy to find a love interest or just that they think people wouldn’t want to see that?”
Tybee responds, “Both!”
Both… BOTH!? You genuinely think the push back came from people on your team being so rock stupid they thought it was IMPOSSIBLE for a overweight person to find love? That it was ACTUALLY impossible and not just people being shitty?
These two act like god damn space aliens sometimes…
Travis describes the end result as, “Really good and doesn’t feel forced at all!”
And Tybee, after basking in the adoration for a bit, pivots her own argument from, ‘people didn’t think the audience would like AND some people could not comprehend a fat person finding love’ to, ‘actually the company was falling apart, everyone hated everyone else and the push back came from person A rejecting the idea just cus person B was for it.’
Which, tellingly, Tybee JUST got done saying she was the one who was pushing for this to happen, so the push back apparently had more to do with allot of people on the production just really not liking her and disagreeing with her on principle. Which is either a serious self report on just how unlikable she is OR her developing a hell of a victim complex and declaring people only pushed back on the idea because she was in favor of it.
Either way, this show sounds like a fucking nightmare on the back end…
She also apparently declared that another character, ‘Scar’ could NOT have a love interest because then the show would be to cliche.
Which, you know, I’ve not seen this show myself, but if you have a character named ‘Scar’ who it would be ‘cliche’ to give a love interest too, I’m guessing it’s because he’s already the bad boy loner and you named that character ‘Scar’ and your fat guy ‘Twig’ so I’d REALLY not be all that worried about falling into cliches at this point…
Travis then declares that, ‘tropes are fine actually’ because we rely on them for story telling. That he likes to just put things he already likes into his stories and that ‘The Heroes Journey’ is a ‘good trope’ because, and I quote:
Travis: Because I don’t have to think to hard about [my story], because I already know how the Hero’s Journey storyline works.
Don’t worry Travis, I already kinda figured you didn’t put much thought into your stories.
Also ‘The Hero’s Journey’ isn’t a trope, its a (flawed) theory about how all stories, especially mythology, fit into a fixed broad story structure. It’s just treated like a writing guide cus George Lucas used it as a reference for the Star Wars movies and then overstated just how closely his movies matched up to the Hero’s Journey in an interview which lead English teachers the world over to leap at the chance to teach their students about Joseph Campbell by going, “Did you know that the Odyssey AND Star Wars follow the same story structure? It’s true!”
I’m getting REAL distracted, but just… god so many rants, so little time…
Oh, also apparently ALL of this was just to get back to the idea of changing things in adaptations and Tybee’s theory that the problem with basically ALL adaptations is… they change too much and thus they suck. They don’t do enough fan services and her show was good because it did allot of fanserives, I guess.
Apparently the McElroy Brothers and Client all love Final Fantasy, but Travis was DEEPLY offended by The Spirits Within because it ‘didn’t have enough Final Fantasy stuff in it!’
Ah, but Travis feels like movies based on things MUST be made for the fans explicitly and exclusively, BUT they cannot do TOO MUCH fan service or else its pandering, but too little and its a betrayal!
So if you make something based on a show or movie or game or comic, make sure it hits that fine line between too much and too little fan service or else Travis and Tybee will be PISSED! What is that line? Eh, you’ll figure it out, probably…
Travis uses as an example, ‘The King Killer Chronicles’ and how the main character has red hair and its mentioned a number of times, so if the character does NOT have red hair in an adaptation, ‘what the FUCK are you even doing?’ Which just makes me think about all the terrible wigs used to make characters ‘accurate’ and… well I guess we now know who keeps demanding that shit.
Hmm… Travis brings up Harry Potter as another example and declares, “Not everything can make it into an adaptation, but if you had a teacher who was a woman and made them a man, then what are you doing? Do you think the fans won’t notice!? You didn’t swap that for time, you just fucking changed it!”
Tybee: Ya and people will say it doesn’t matter, but it does! It changes the interpersonal relationships within the story! Every peace of it matters!
Travis: And it doesn’t matter if its a minor character with three lines of duologue, the description of that character matters and someone might love that character because their three lines really spoke to them and made them feel scene and they wrote hundreds of books worth of fan-fiction about them! Or that was their avatar on twitter and YOU made them a man or made them have long hair when they where meant to have short hair or made them brunet when they where SUPPOSED to be blond! And sure, maybe that’s just 0.1% of your audience who that effects, but [laughing] that 0.1% of the audience and a following and can tell everyone to not watch your movie! Like, make it for them!
These people… This is one to one just the Ghostbuster fan complaint they had at the start! They are doing the same thing as the people they where complaining about, but hey… at least they are being woke about it. At least its about gender bending a woman to be a man and not say… race bending a white character black… they’d never complain about-
Tybee: And the same thing is happening with the Dark Tower adaption right now, with Idris Elba playing Roland and that WILL effect the story, because as I understand it, he has a relationship with a woman who is black and so him being white is important to the story!
I’m going to walk into the desert, pursued by a gunslinger…
Travis begins explaining that, no, Roland being black isn’t actually going to mess up the story, that Tybee is thinking of the relationship between Eddie and Susannah.
[Cutting a VERY long section talking about Stephen King. As a Mainer and a writer I have many thoughts on him, good and bad and that would double this recap’s length.]
Travis ends off by doing a REAL weird bit where he goes, “I hadn’t thought about it till now, but having your main, awesome, badass gunslinger character ALSO be black? Weeeeeell that is INTERESTING!”
HUGE ‘I’d have voted for Obama a third time!’ Energy.
Tybee, seeming to realize she probably just stepped in it back peddles with, “I’m not saying it will change it for the worse, it might be great! It might add something new and he’s an incredible actor! So I’m sure it will be great! But I do… uh, you know, its just a case where someones color does effect their interpersonal relationships so I wonder… I just know some people will be upset so…”
Travis declares he’s going to hit Tybee with a hard one and then asks:
Travis: Do you think their is a defensible stance for someone to say they don’t like the new Ghostbusters because of the changes they made to the original?
Travis, for the love of… I DON’T AGREE WITH THIS, BUT BY YOUR OWN LOGIC YES! 100%! You genuinely argued changing a characters hair style was indefensible and Tybee threw out that as far as she’s concerned even a progressive change like adding MORE diversity is problematic, how could EITHER of you at this point argue that their is NO reason for someone to be upset about a Ghostbusters remake where all the characters are gender flipped and the plot is reworked from scratch!?
Again, it’s not even about agreeing with that point myself, at this point YOU have constructed a black and white, all or nothing version of this argument where ANY change is too much and now are forced to look at a situation where EVERYTHING is changed and YOU are going to ask if its even remotely possible for someone to be slightly valid in not liking that!?
Tybee: No. Because no one took that movie out of their hands. They still have it.
Travis smugly: Exactly!
I’m so fucking mad I’m animorphing into an alt right grifter! AAAAAAHHHH I AM SO FULL OF FACTS AND LOGIC!!! DEBATE ME!!! DEEEEBATE MEEEEEE!!!
Okay, I’m back.
Travis: That’s a great point Tybee! Because I was starting to feel like a hypocrite! Because of this and that and the things I said, but your right, it’s not like they have an adaptation and its bad, instead, they have a movie and its called-
Both: Ghostbuster!
I can’t be wrong, the person who agrees with everything I say said I’m right!
Travis starts gassing Tybee up for being so smart as they start patting one another on the back and my urge to rampage through Tokyo as a giant monster grows…
Tybee: And I don’t think their is a defensible stance for like, saying, [mokingly] ‘I want my Roland white!’, but I do, I mean, in terms of framing it as like… it changes interpersonal relationships… it’s interesting. But I don’t care, cus I didn’t read the books! But I do wonder how it will make people feel who really love them.
God I hate them so fucking much.
Like you can just stop at, ‘Arguing Roland HAS to be white is dumb and kinda racist’, you don’t then need to follow it up with, ‘UNLESS you frame that dumb and racist take in a way I’d find smart sounding, in which case…’
Travis talks about reading the Dark Tower and finishing it, but getting caught up repeatedly on Wizard and Glass which… ya you know, if Travis was going to get stuck on anything, it would be the book that’s a tragic love story instead of a gun slinging adventure yarn.
And he uses this just to say, “You know… it [Roland being black] didn’t bother me!” In the tone of someone declaring, ‘I actually found this 10k bike ride very refreshing and not tiring at all!’
Travis then expresses, “The one upside to people complaining when you make a black, gay lesbian is that they then cannot complain when you make a white character black!” Which… no? What the fuck does that even mean? Someone complaining about a diverse character is not going to go, ‘dang you got me!’ if you then make a previously white character black… what the fuck are you even talking about!?
I’m losing my fucking mind, I need a break, be back soon…
Tybee, continuing on the Dark Tower talk: I think you have a responsibility, when adapting a book, to change it to match the current social climate and not the social climate the book was released in! And if you leave that out, if you don’t take that into consideration, your making a HUGE mistake and being totally irresponsible!
Okay, whatever. I, again, agree in general with this take, update adaptations as needed to make them feel modern and representative, don’t just use the fact that allot of old books were written by crusty old white Europeans and Americans to refuse to cast people of color or women or queer people, est. But to hear THESE TWO go on for over half an hour about how changing ANYTHING in an adaption is a sin worthy of damnation, but then when that classhes with their self-purported progressive values it’s suddenly like, “Can you imagine someone getting bent out of shape over something as trivial as changing a characters race or gender?”
They are just such massive pricks!
Travis: Okay, I agree with you, except on one thing…
Tybee: Oh ya, I mean I’m just coming up with all of this on the spot!
Travis: Because I feel like your right, but- except under the circumstance where the thing that is happening is..
Jesus Christ, he’s getting so worked up, it sounds like he’s about to cum! Like hes taking quick, short breaths, sounding increasingly tense, but excited and then…
Travis: Is like the impetus, is like… it MEANS something… LIKE FOR EXAMPLE! It means something that someone called someone a F*GOT!
Tybee: No no no! I’m not saying leave THAT out! That’s not what I’m saying! I’m saying, story like what your describing should be left as is. I think we should explore the edges of violence, I don’t think we should pull punches, I don’t think we should pull punches…
TYBEE IN THE FIRST EPISODE OF THE SHOW YOU ADVOCATED THAT EXACT THING! I have the receipts, mother fucker! I HAVE YOUR ASS!
Tybee: I’m saying… Gone Girl didn’t need to be released when it was released.
Travis asks what she meant by that and Tybee immediately walks back her own point by saying Gone Girl discredits Me Too and thus should have been banned.
She then concludes by saying that if you CAN make Roland black and it won’t change the story, you should.
This, as a reminder, all started because she herself brought up making Roland black as an example of a BAD change that should not have been made in adapting The Dark Tower.
Oh here we go, it’s Diversity Hires time!
Travis brings up that it’s ironic because Idris Elba should have been hired as the best person for the job, because in a perfect world everyone would be equally represented and race blind casting would be a thing.
Tybee then equates this to ‘Affirmative Action’ and says, “Some people equate it to equality, it’s not, its a step towards equality. ALLOT of people say it doesn’t work, but I donno, I’m not trying to comment on if it does or doesn’t, I’m just saying in terms of what it’s SUPPOSED to do, it’s not equality, its just the precursor to it.”
Travis: (Sigh) You know, Brent and I were talking about this the other day and I don’t think it made it to air, but we were talking about like… sometimes it can seem like people who are fighting for equality or people who are people who are fighting for ‘blank’ are pushing TOO HARD. Are pushing for MORE then what equality is…
OH BOY! I was so nervous they where going to have the bog standard liberal take on this and just go, ‘ya people who complain about diversity are bad’, but NO! We have Travis declaring that equality HAS GONE TO FAR! Affirmative action and diversity hiring has moved past equality and into reverse racism land! LETS GO CRAZY!
Tybee: Ya.
Good to know you agree Tybee, would hate to leave you out of this…
Travis: And the realization I think the world needs to come to is that if you only push back as hard as they are pushing back it doesn’t move the needle. You need to push the need harder to push the needle back to zero, because we are not at zero yet.
Wait… your saying that we DO need to push harder… because we aren’t actually at equality and thus need to push back to a point of true equality? Fuuuuck are you going to turn out to be reasonable on this?
But then what was the whole, ‘they are pushing too hard and pushing for more then equality’ shit!? Ugh, let’s roll this forward and I’ll report back after they’ve had a chance to clarify their point more.
Okay, OKAY! I see the argument they are making now!
Travis’s argument is that we are CURRENTLY unequal and that we need ‘radical leftists like Bernie Sanders’ and black people playing traditional white roles to help push things back to the middle. AND THEN, once we are in the middle, back to TRUE equality, then he’s going to start pushing back against the left and progressives because THEN they’d be pushing for TOO MUCH diversity and progress! In Travis and Tybee’s ideal world, we would be perfectly centered, with equal pressure from progressives and racists to ensure no one achieves any movement one way or the other.
Travis is only a progressive because, like a true 2eD&D druid, he feels like the balance of the world has been thrown off and he MUST return us to a place of perfect balance between good and evil, law and chaos.
ACHIEVEMENT UNLOCKED: The World’s Most Laughable Centrist
Tybee: And here’s the deal, and this will make me really emotional, but I’m going to talk about it anyway… It’s not fair. It’s not fair at all! I recently was up for a- Sorry, I’m going to cry, I was up for like, my dream job! (Actually starts to audible tear up) AND I DIDN’T GET IT! I lost it to A DIVERSITY HIRE! (Voice shaking) And like… that ‘person’, it was a black woman, and I was told by a friend who was a producer, you did EVERYTHING RIGHT! You were perfect in every way! And they NEEDED to hire someone of color… (tiny, breath) And… their is- the intersectional feminist in me is like ‘okay! Okay!’ (actually starts crying) I want to see women of color on screen… (sounding legit bitter as fuck) I want that… BUT IT DOESN’T MEAN I DIDN’T LOSE MY DREAM JOB!
Travis, sounding totally unemotional: Yep.
Tybee: IT’S NOT FAIR! IT’S NOT! BUT… I don’t get to be mad and I don’t get to throw a shit fit! (sniff) And I don’t get to decide now that I don’t like affirmative actions and diversity hires! I either have to be FOR IT AND FUCKING STICK TO IT! Or I’m a coward… and self serving. And I’m not either of those things.
Travis, still sounding detached: I agree.
Tybee: So I will watch that show and I will support that girl and you won’t hear me bitch about it publicly- (realizes in real time she’s bitching about it publicly) I’m talking about it now, NOT bitching about it, but just to say that while people will say its unfair, and it is, imagine all the chances I got because I was white…
Travis: Ya.
Tybee: And like, it came to the big one and I lost… (laughs bitterly) And that SUCKS!
Travis: Ya.
Tybee: But… it’s better… and I’m not saying, aren’t I a saint? For not being upset? I’m FUCKING UPSET! I’m fucking upset!
Travis: But I think it’s very respectable to realize like, you can’t draw a line between how it effects you personally and how it effects the world.
Oh yes, I am very sure that you find it VERY respectable for someone to not understand how to put their own personal feelings behind their understanding that the world is bigger then them, Travis, I bet you find that a VERY admirable quality!
And Tybee continues, talking about how much money she would have made, how much work she’d get, how this was a BIG DEAL for her and how she’s angry and upset and how she earned this and deserves it and it was basically stolen from her, but, you know… it doesn’t matter because if she wants to claim to be an intersectional feminist, she actually has to be one.
Nothing tells me your over something and cool with it and hold no grudges like a tearful rant about how much you hate that thing and have not, nor will ever get over how much you wish it had gone differently.
Travis thinks this was all an excellent point because most people in Tybee’s position would not be as mature as her and look at it and go, “Damn this is a thing that was taken away from me!” Rather then focusing on the fact that it’s about the wider scale issues of inequality.
Travis… your co-host just got done literally crying about how this was taken away from her. Where you actually listening or do you just turn off your brain till your allowed to talk again?
Tybee: I want young girls of color to have people to look up to.
Travis: EXACTLY! Because in a perfect world, we won’t need affirmative action or diversity hires! Cus it won’t be necessary! And I see people go, ‘this is unfair to white people!’ And it’s not, because we need to balance the scales because eventually, when their is equal representation across the board-
Tybee: IT IS UNFAIR!
Travis: Oh, ya it is unfair! If we are talking about, on paper, statistically, sure. But we just need to balance the scales so we can all start operating from a level playing field.
Tybee: The problem is people cannot zoom out… [allot of waffling then] But I CAN zoom out and so you better fucking shine, [because you stole my job], but I support this.
God these two…
So Travis’s goal is basically, ‘make everything equal, that way, we can have a TRUE meritocracy! With no more racism to get in the way of the best of the best rising to the top, unfettered by inequality!”
And Tybee’s point is, ‘I just want everyone to know, diversity hires suck, but we have to put up with them, even though they suck and hurt me personally, but I’m dealing with it, so so can you.’
Travis praises Tybee for being brave and honest and then says he loves her, followed by a sudden pivot to, “ANYWAY THAT’S GONNA DO IT FOR US THIS WEEK!”
Well that wasn’t so bad and I got it down to… 7.9k words!? Ah hell…
Okay, well, sorry for another long one, but I’ll see you next time Travnation!
I am still hoping to eventually do Amnesty, but for now, as long as I can keep this site working, I’ll keep the Interrobang flame alive!
Oh shit last note, while playing the outro Travis hit me with this:
Travis: We are glad you all like listening to us and if their is, heh, some small, tiny subset of people who disagree with everything we say and just hate me and Tybee, well we still appreciate you!
Thanks?
Okay… oh and then they talk about how all their fans (who sent in photos???) are so sexy and so ‘bang-able’.
I’m out, I’m leaving, I might need to start Amnesty next just to wash that out of my mouth! EW EW EW!