u/Few-Poetry1085

I feel like despite Roe having a few inconsistent services, I feel like her making it to a Black Jacket was not too bad as even most of her poor services weren’t even too bad compared to Clemenza who has had a lot of bizarre services. I mean his badass plea in Guy’s elimination episode is what spared him over Guy so yeah. Tell me your thoughts!

Both were delusional and way over their heads but I found Scott’s moments more hilarious and funny compared to Monique. Especially in his elimination episode where he quotes, “This time will f**king die if I’m not there!” 🤣. What are your thoughts?

1. Cheyenne(S21); Her first Black Jacket service with her struggles on the fish station.

2. Leigh(S22); Her first Black Jacket service where she kept opening the oven door a lot and not knowing how to slice Wellingtons correctly.

3. Brandon(S23); His first Black Jacket service where he struggled on the meat station.

4. Anaiya(S24); Her final 10 service where her and Alexandra didn’t work well with each other on the fish station and the fact that Anaiya had her moments where she rubbed her teammates the wrong way. Plus it was even more interesting that the team called her out to Ramsay during the Final 10 elimination ceremony.

Note; Wow! Pretty much almost all of them(except for Anaiya) bombed at winning the season in their First Black Jacket service. Ain’t that something!

1. Kimberly(S16); Probably her run overall having too many bumps along the road despite having a few positive moments.

2. Robyn(S17); I guess her struggles earlier on before she got transferred over to the blue team and even with a few good highlights, she was never really winning against the likes of someone like Nick or Benjamin.

3. Heather(S18); Probably Steak Night with T but even then, that was more on T’s part for being a dick towards her and not communicating well with her.

4. Amber(S19); Her not adapting well enough with being on the blue team and her slow downward spiral from the final 12(Josh’s boot episode) to her boot episode. Plus even the blue team near Black Jackets were getting tired of her whiny behavior.

5. Steve(S20); His final 9 service where he was not communicating with his teammates and as a bonus, his final 5 round where he put out a poor plea compared to his strong plea at the final 9.

1. Susan(S11); Her rivalry with Lamb and her inexperience as a whole

2. Kaisha(S12); Probably her Southern Night service serving tons of raw chicken and I have to go with her Charity Night too.

3. Santos(S13); Getting kicked out individual in half of his services and not standing out too much.

4. Josh(S14); His services from the final 10 to final 6 being mediocre with his Charity night(F8) being the most disastrous one.

5. Manda(S15); Her not standing up to Frank enough at times and having a bumpy ride in her run in general.

1. Van(S6); I say his argument with JP in Ep 2 in the dining room table over his poor performance on tableside.

2. Ed(S7); His hungover episode at the final 9 leading towards his downfall and probably his final service in the First Black Jacket service.

3. Sabrina(S8); I say her teammates not respecting her as a leader and her not doing enough to get along with them as a whole.

4. Jennifer(S9); Her final service in the 2nd final 5 service where she was lacking a voice definitely did her a number in her at that point.

5. Robyn(S10); Her final 11 service alongside getting into petty arguments with most of her teammates.

1. Jimmy(S1); I say his opening night performance or maybe his final 6 service where Michael had to cook everything for him on the fish station.

2. Garrett(S2); I probably have to go with him flicking off at Ramsay during the final 6 punishment task.

3. Josh(S3); Besides his ejection episode, I probably have to go with his final 6 performance on meat to the point where Ramsay even whispers in his ear saying that he can’t cook and that his elimination was nearby.

4. Matt(S4); His signature dish! Honorable mention to his episode 4 service where he served pink chicken to the kids.

5. Giovanni(S5); His episode 3 service where he had a ton of undercooked steak returned to the kitchen despite him owning a Steakhouse for a living.

With both Seasons 2 and Season 8 being one of the least Talented seasons, how do you think these 2 winners would’ve done if they were both on a separate season. Like a Nona vs Virginia finale and a Heather Vs Russell finale?