Some of the arguments I saw (My Villain Gang Deku againts Deku Canon)
Clarification: these aren't mine; I got them from others. That doesn't mean I believe them, but they did give me a good laugh (Some are repeated), So, I want to know what you all think. Personally, I believe canon Izuku wins. From what I remember of reading My Villain Gang, it's more of a statement than proof, and they didn't really demonstrate that they were on par with... or even better than the canon versions
Here they are:
"You're wrong, it wasn't All Might Prime, it was an All Might stronger than his Prime version, as stated by the villain Deku himself. Besides, you only have to think a little: the All Might who fought the villain Deku had One For All at 100% plus his inherited quirks. Basically, he was like the Deku from season seven, but stronger, since Deku uses his 45% plus the combination of inherited quirks."
"First of all, Deku also needed help against Shigaraki. Literally, if Nagant hadn't helped him, Deku would have died (or well, he wouldn't have died because Shigaraki wanted One For All). Also, you're forgetting that Deku is a ticking time bomb. With all his quirk combinations, Deku can only last 5 minutes fighting; after that, he'll have to take a long break."
"No, as I already told you, Deku faced an All Might more powerful than the Deku from season seven, although he needed the Brave One For All quirk. Keep in mind that..." He could withstand a fight against him, and Deku (Canon) with all his Quirks was like a ticking time bomb. Do you think All Might was nerfed? Even with OFA, the machine that amplifies his scientist friend's Quirks, and his inherited Quirks? He also showed the most overpowered one of all, Gear Shift (you can tell by his eyes).
"It was said that All Might was better than in his prime. I recommend watching the All Might vs. Villain Deku fight if you don't remember that dialogue. Now you're telling me this because it was never said that he was superior to the Deku of season seven. It's a matter of logic, because All Might had 100%, which is higher than 45%. Regarding the experience with Quirks, you're right, but All Might knew how to make the most of them."
"It was said that All Might was better than in his prime. I recommend watching the All Might vs. Villain Deku fight if you don't remember that dialogue. Now you're telling me this because it was never said that he was superior to the Deku of season seven. It's a matter of logic, because All Might had 100%, which is higher than 45%. Regarding the experience with Quirks, you're right, but All Might knew how to take advantage of them."
" "Look, I don't think you read anything about this discussion, but I'll summarize it for you. Villain Deku's feat is enduring a battle against All Might, an All Might stronger than in his prime. Furthermore, Deku's low durability when using Gear Shift is a major disadvantage. While Villain Deku doesn't have regeneration, he can tank All Might's 100% + Gear Shift attacks. These attacks are superior to those of Deku from season seven, since he uses a combination of inherited quirks + 45% of One For All. In other words, Villain Deku doesn't win because he's more powerful; he wins because he has greater durability, experience, IQ/BIQ, combat experience, and his multiple quirks."
"But the villainous Deku did it in much less time, and he was also able to fight Bakugo in One For All after facing All Might at 100%, and he also proved to be more intelligent in battle than the hero Deku."
"Villain Deku is more resilient. Don't forget that Deku with all his quirks is a ticking time bomb. Villain Deku is also faster, since he can teleport. In battle, Villain Deku wins, since he's the same as Deku, only more mature, cold, and calculating. He also has experience, since he became a villain before Deku became a hero in the original timeline. Furthermore, he didn't waste 10 months training his physique. He also fought an All Might who was in better shape than in his prime and won due to his stamina (although he received help from the Brave One's quirk). In my opinion, Villain Deku wins with extreme difficulty."
"You're wrong. First, in a dialogue, Villain Deku himself tells All Might, with all of his quirks..." Ofa, who is in a better state than in his prime, Deku is a ticking time bomb, because with all his quirks, especially Gear Shift, Deku can only fight for 5 minutes, and then he won't be able to move. Villain Deku already has experience fighting long battles with people who are ticking time bombs, and he possesses many quirks that would help him wear down and withstand a fight against Deku."
I refuse to say who said it, because, although I have a completely different opinion than what they said, I don't want them to end up insulting him, but, if they ask, I can take pictures of the real comments, of course, with the names censored.