u/Fun-Comb-2133

If I wanted to stay silent I would have played Werewolf.

At this point it's usually one good and two evil, so the ST is just silencing every good player and letting evil gaslight the remaining.

And I won't be putting up with it anymore. If you don't have the fabled on your game that lets you ask for silence then telling anyone they're not allowed to speak is breaking the rules of the game.

And no "the first minute is for the dead, then the next two is only living players" is not an acceptable compromise.

I know that Anathema exists, but keeping it updated for online games has always been a pain, especially once you start making Custom Charms or Custom items and need to install library patches to keep it from deleting your character when you try reading your player's characters.

So I set out to make a 2nd Edition Character Sheet that is accessible online and editable, unlike the pdfs Anathema exports.

It is not set to do any calculations yet(except on the XP page)

The document is open to commenting if you have any cool suggestions.

So spoiler, it did turn out to be an Atheist game

I was the Engineer, the Demons on script were Al-hadikia and Po. Someone had claimed Atheist but no one really believed them.

I notice Mezepheles was on the script and decide that my goal is to win for myself, not to win for Town. If it’s not an Atheist game then I can fish for the secret word and hopefully turn evil. If it is Athiest, Mezepheles is very hard to fake as Storyteller.

Thats all just the fun background, the problem is that the moment I pointed to Mezepheles my Storyteller looked like I’d slapped him.

I chose not to mention the reaction and try to play like I hadn’t seen it but is using a Storyteller social read acceptable? Further, is using social reads from the Storyteller acceptable even if there isn’t Atheist on the script?