u/GianTesto

Hey everyone,

I’m looking for an honest assessment from experienced sellers to help me move my shop away from that "generic POD" look and toward a more established brand feel. I’ve been hitting a plateau and I suspect my presentation might be the bottleneck.

Per sub rule #2, here is my shop link for context: GREATTRASHDESIGNS

I’m specifically looking for your perspective on:

• Mockup Quality: Do my current mockups look too "templated"? I’m trying to achieve a vintage/bootleg streetwear aesthetic, but I'm worried the digital overlays aren't translating well to perceived value.
• SEO vs. Readability: Are my titles too stuffed with keywords, or are they effectively capturing the horror/cult film niche?
• Brand Cohesion: Does the "vibe" feel consistent across the banner, logo, and listings, or does it feel like a random collection of shirts?
• Conversion Friction: From a buyer's perspective, is there anything in my shop policies or item descriptions that feels like a red flag or a "weak link"?

I’m genuinely trying to build this into a long-term brand, so please don't hold back on the constructive criticism. Thanks in advance!

Hey everyone — I’ve been building a small streetwear brand inspired by vintage bootlegs, horror films, cult cinema, metal merch, and worn-in 90s aesthetics.

I’m trying to create pieces that feel closer to collectible vintage tees than generic print-on-demand designs, and I’d really appreciate feedback from people into streetwear and brand building.

Mainly looking for opinions on:

• Overall brand identity
• Graphic direction
• Product presentation
• Mockups
• Pricing
• What feels strong / weak
• What you’d improve moving forward

Store: GREATTRASHDESIGNS

Open to honest criticism — I’m trying to grow this into a real long-term brand. Thanks 🙏