WIBTA if I tell a new friend I’m not interested in him, even though he hasn’t explicitly confessed to me yet?
Hello, before I start it is important to note that I am a gay man.
A few months ago, I got a crush on a guy, and I'm going to call him Luca. Luca is simply beautiful in the truest sense of the word. He has beautiful hair and eyes, but internally he is also a very sweet, emotional, and thoughtful person. I like him romantically, but I also really like him platonic-ally and he is an amazing person to be around.
We've become really good friends and even though he is bisexual, and I would totally want to date him in a heartbeat, I am content with us being friends as long as I can keep him in my life. We do have conversations that feel a little flirty to me and some signs say he might like me back, but I'm not sure, I'm happy being his friend, and I feel no need to risk it.
Because of this crush, I haven't really been interested in dating anyone else. I want to be clear that my crush on him isn't all-consuming, but I think would be disloyal to any partner to date them while still loving Luca this much as a friend. So I suppose, while my situation is probably unstable and can't be permanent, I am perfectly happy just being his friend for the meantime.
Queue Mason, another queer male friend of mine. Mason is a newer friend and we've been hanging out more recently. He flirts with me a bit and at a sleepover he started caressing my arm a little. In hindsight I should've pulled my arm away, but I didn't want to hurt his feelings.
To me it really feels like Mason likes me, but I don't know. I am all for communication, but I don't know if it's necessary here. I'm really afraid of coming of as a total douche assuming every guy that wants to be my friend is into me. I'm worried that if I go to Mason and tell him I'm not interested in a relationship right now, he will be weirded out and I will lose him because he never liked me. On the other hand, if I don't say anything it could give him the wrong impression and lead to a messier situation down the line.
I really could go either way on this, so I'm very open to the honest and unbiased opinions of you guys. Is it appropriate to have a conversation with Mason? Should I just make more of an effort to clearly shut down his flirting?