What do you when your writing reads like a "comedic summary of a serious work"?
I have gotten the critique a few times that whenever I try to write serious fiction it reads like a comedic summary of a longer serious fiction.
Something like Overly sarcastic production's journey to the west, or a crashcourse video about a classic piece of literature. Or one of those youtubers who summarize analogue horror.
When I bring my writing to crit groups, and don't specify that I am not trying to be comedic, people always launch into complementing my jokes and giving ideas for punching up the punchlines, when i didn't intend for their to be any jokes at all.
The big thing seems to be that folk's don't think my characters art like they are in a serious version of the events they are in, they read like the situations they are in have the gravity of a monty python sketch. And that critique makes sense, but I don't know how to get past writing like that.
Have any of you had this sort of issue? What would you recommend for getting past it?