I’m sick of hearing “I’ve done this for x amount of years.” Like that automatically means it’s good.
Sorry this is gonna be part rant, part vent and part kinda looking for advice.
Started coaching youth sports about 5 years ago. Started with a bunch of dads coaching our sons in youth football.
We were part of the youth program that fed into a high school that annually competed for championships. The team has a few dudes on D1 rosters and 3 current starters in the NFL.
Now what made this made program so good was the total buy in by everyone from the 8u all the way up to the high school.
The high school provided the playbook (scaled down accordingly for younger teams) and provided oversight and quality control for the youth program. We took that same playbook, and that same system and built on it every year so that when “the dads” handed off players to the high school coaches it was a seamless transition and a culture had already been established.
Players got 4,5,6 years of development. Positional training, EDDs, etc and actually understood the game.
Last year we moved across the country and now live in a town where the football team is absolutely horrendous. I’m talking HS football team having a parade down main street for winning one game a season.
We played youth ball last year, and it was just the Wild West of dudes screaming at kids and making them run into each other as hard as they could… zero fundamentals just backyard ball. I wrote it off as just a bad experience with the youth league.
We wrapped up spring practice earlier this year for the middle school level and now we’re into our regular season practices and it’s basically the exact same thing. They brought in new coaches at the HS and he hand picked the MS coach so they could be on the same page. Both who were supposed to have had great success at their previous roles in another state.
So far there has been ZERO development. Handful of returners getting 100% of the reps for everything, no EDDs, half the kids have never played a down of football and can’t get in a stance, but let’s jump right to coverages, blocking assignments, etc.
I’ve been sitting back quietly observing (volunteer assistant coach atm) but all I ever hear is “I’ve been doing this 30 years” blah blah blah.
I feel like anyone can field 11 athletes with some skill and win a game or two… but that’s not coaching imo. It’s no wonder this town is perennially bad at football.
Gotta go do other things now, so end of rant.