
SH's act 2 choice is so funny if you know how it works
I'm obviously talking about the Nightsong-choice. There is [an excellent video](https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=YdNEya-Np5U) breaking down the specifics, but it ultimately comes down to this: There are so-called "Nightsonh"-points you can "score" by performing certain actions connected to SH's past or gaining her trust. Those actions include (but aren’t limited to):
- Saying that her "training" from the Mother Superior sounds like abuse
- Asking her about curing her wound
- Pointing out she is wearing a moonstone during her flashback-scene
- Giving her an idol of Shar
Those points make it harder or easier or harder to convince her to spare the Nightsong. At least they should, because, for some reason, having enough points actually removes the dialogue that allows you to convince her, so getting them actually makes it more likely for her to kill the Nightsong, which is likely a bug. But that’s not all: If you have more than forty approval and let SH decide for herself, she'll always spare the Nightsong, no matter what.
So there are two things I find to very funny about this: First, getting to know SH better and getting her to question her faith without enough approval actually makes it worse than just not talking to her about any of this. And second, one of the easiest ways to get SH to have enough approval is by letting her complete rituals for Shar and agreeing that her religion sounds good.
Of course, the second point holds some truth because finding acceptance and a friend can actually help people get away from unhealthy influences irl too. It’s just a bit ironic that supporting her cult actually makes it more likely for her to abandon it.
(And yes I know Shart is more common, but SH saves three more letters so that’s what I'm going with in order to minmax.)