Weird Aquapolis and Skyridge phenomenon: 'common' (circle) rarity E-reader reverse-holos are more expensive than 'rare' (star) reverse-holos. Why is this?
I've been really into reverse holos from Expedition, Aquapolis, and Skyridge lately and have noticed a strange phenomenon. I'm not sure if this applies to Expedition as much, but Aquapolis and Skyridge reverse holos that are 'common' rarity are much more difficult to find and expensive than reverse-holo 'rare' (star) cards. This is incredibly odd to me, a circle rarity being worth much more than a star rarity?
For instance, Natu and Xatu reverse holos from Skyridge: there are a dozen or more reverse holo Xatu's on Ebay right now (for North America), yet only 5 copies of Natu (four bgs graded 8.5 and above and a PSA, no raws).
Last Natu PSA 10 sale = $1160
Last Xatu PSA 10 sale = $750
Another example is Aquapolis Oddish reverse vs Vileplume reverse-holos
On ebay in North America there are only two copies of Oddish (a raw and a psa9). Psa 9 selling for $216. However there are 13 Vileplumes available, with a psa 9 going for $144
Pricecharting says:
PSA 10 reverse holo Oddish = $1184
PSA 10 reverse Vileplume = $626
These are only two examples but I've seen this with most common rarity Aquapolis and Skyridge reverse-holos. Does anyone have an explanation as to why the circle 'common' rarity reverse-holo ereaders are so much more rare than a star symbol 'rare' reverse-holo? I thought collecting vintage Oddish cards would be cheap, and it was until these reverse-holo 😅