Embody vs. Aeron Size C for wide builds (not just "bigger builds") — Any advice on dealing with the plastic frame edges?
First off, I really hate foam chairs. I have never sat in one that didn't either bottom out, like the Steelcase Gesture, or feel like a brick, like most gaming chairs. Because of that, the logical choice seems to be an Aeron or an Embody, since both use actual suspension systems instead of relying on spongy foam.
The problem is that these chairs don't seem to keep wide people in mind. I initially bought an Aeron Size C, but the hard plastic sides jammed straight into my hips. Adding a Purple seat cushion helped elevate my hips above the frame, but that threw off the ergonomics of the entire chair. Once I was boosted up, my lower back couldn't properly connect with the PostureFit lumbar support. I ended up letting my girlfriend use the chair, even though she is technically too small for it.
I thought the Embody would be better because Herman Miller claims it has 21 inches of seating space. I sat in one for about an hour or two at an outlet store, and it felt great initially until I noticed some familiar pain in my hips. When I examined the seat closely, I saw that just like the Aeron, it has a rigid plastic frame running around the actual seating area. It is slightly better because the top padding covers the edges, but come on, Herman Miller. That is not a true 21 inches of usable seating width.
I also didn't love that the backrest isn't as wide as the Aeron's, especially since I naturally have a wide upper back and broad shoulders. However, I thought the lower back support on the Embody was way better, which made the overall back support feel superior.
So, are there any widely built users out there who have suggestions or experience with this? Did any of you eventually just get used to the Embody's side edges? Right now, I can grab an Embody on sale for $900 with no returns or warranty, and I feel like saving over a grand might be worth the risk. Or would it be smarter to wait for a Black Friday sale and buy one brand new with a full warranty?
To be clear, I am specifically asking wider users because this isn't just about being heavy. Some guys are heavy without having a physically wide frame, which is a very different issue when it comes to hard seat boundaries. Any advice would be hugely appreciated!