u/LostMyAccountToo

Thursday night I joined Josh Zeman to go through what I think is one of the more interesting rabbit holes surrounding Rex Heuermann.

An old online account using the name LongIslandAndy has left behind a pretty strange digital trail. Some of what we found lines up in ways that are difficult for me to ignore. There are numerous overlaps with Gilgo, The Killing Season, Amber Costello, Amber’s sister Kim Overstreet and Other pieces leave legitimate questions.

To be clear, we have NOT confirmed that LongIslandAndy was Rex Heuermann. That distinction matters. But we have actionable items in okay to move the needle towards confirmation

But if this account can eventually be connected to Rex, the implications are pretty incredible. It would potentially give us a window into what he was reading, where he was online, and possibly how closely he was following discussion surrounding Gilgo before his arrest.

There is another layer that I find fascinating.
Josh made The Killing Season, probably the most well-known documentary examining the Long Island Serial Killer case before Rex’s arrest. If LongIslandAndy really was Rex, then while Josh was publicly hunting for answers about the unidentified killer, Rex may have been somewhere in that same online world watching people search for him.

We go through what we found, what actually matches, what doesn’t, and where I think we need to be careful.
I’m curious what Reddit finds as well. Watch it skeptically. Try to poke holes in it.

On August 8, 1990, landscapers working at a home off Chateau Drive/Bagatelle Road in Melville, NY made a disturbing discovery: the body of an unidentified light-skinned Hispanic/Colombian male (estimated age 25–35), shot 5 times.

What makes this case stand out immediately is the restraint involved: he was found with a single handcuff locked onto his left wrist, with the other cuff dangling open.

This case is currently featured on Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney’s official Cold Case Portal. In our latest video field report, we visited the dump site off Exit 50 of the Long Island Expressway to analyze the geographic dynamics and behavioral profiling of the scene.

Key Case Details:

• Victim Description: Light-skinned male of Colombian descent, 25–35 years old, ~5'6".
• Clothing: Orange shirt with two men playing volleyball reading “Off Shore of C.A.”, black designer jeans, black loafers.
• Location: Chateau Drive / Bagatelle Road corridor in Melville (straddling borders of Dix Hills, Wheatley Heights, and Wyandanch).
• Cause of Death: Shot 5 times (back, face, head behind left ear, right shoulder).

Behavioral & Forensic Questions:

1. The Handcuffs: Did a struggle ensue during transport, leading the killers to panic and leave the single cuff attached? Or was he held in a secondary location (like a basement or garage chained to a fixture) before being dumped?
2. The Location: Bagatelle Road sits right off Exit 50 of the LIE. Was this a quick, opportunistic dump site chosen by someone familiar with the intersecting town borders, or someone just looking for an easy off-ramp?
3. Forensic Evidence: With metal handcuffs involved during hot August weather, could modern DNA or fingerprint extraction finally yield a match?

https://www.suffolkcountyda.org/cold_case/melville-john-doe/ <- Suffolk County DA Ray Tierney Official Melville John Doe Listing

If you have any information regarding Melville John Doe, contact the Suffolk County DA’s Office at contactda@suffolkcountyny.gov or Suffolk Crime Stoppers at 1-800-220-TIPS.

Hi LISK subreddit,
I’ve been part of this community since around 2021, and I’ve learned a tremendous amount from the discussions here. Every major turn in the case over the last few years has been something I’ve experienced alongside this community. The research, debates, corrections, and insights here have genuinely shaped how I think about these investigations.
Over the past several months, I’ve been working on a documentary about Asian Doe. It’s a victim-focused project that brings together interviews with investigators, journalists, forensic experts, and members of the community, all with one goal: keeping the focus on identifying someone who still doesn’t have their name back.
If you decide to watch it, I’d love to hear your thoughts good or bad. Thanks for being a community that has taught me so much over the years.

After sentencing, most people stop paying attention.

But another process begins:
transport, intake, classification, protective custody, and the institutional reality of prison life.

In this interview, a former Riverhead inmate explains what the process actually looks like for someone like Rex Heuermann.

“The Bus North”

The South Carolina warrant gets overshadowed by the larger Rex Heuermann bail documents, but hidden inside it is a disturbing glimpse into what investigators may have believed he kept behind.

Belts. Paper towels. Electronics. Clothing. Even cat litter.

This video explores the possibility that investigators were searching not just for evidence, but for memory, ritual, and control.

I also wanted this video to remain victim centric while not shying away from the reality of the case itself. These women were real people with lives, families, possessions, routines, and histories. Understanding what investigators were searching for also means understanding what was taken from them.

Would love to hear everyone’s thoughts on the warrant and what stood out to you most.