
Decants from Decantified - 37 decants reviews and clone battles- Part 15: Blue Moon Ginger Dash clone battle! Kismet Lunar Magic vs Mawj Moscow Mule
Decanter review: The decants were PERFECTLY packaged. 0 leaking bottles and all labels intact and clear. 10/10 this time!
I never tried the OG. Took me over a year to find decants of these!
IDK what the hell is wrong with Fragrantica, as both of these don't smell like the notes listed AT ALL!
The profile: Mainly (like, 75%) just very "airy aquatic", with just a hint of citrus-ginger and mint, and Ambroxan that makes you nose-blind in 10 minutes. Good thing I have the wife to clock performance, and I'll use my jacket to hide the scent so I could see what's the dry-down is about...
Okay, dry-down isn't much different. Maybe a tiny bit more musky. Kind of like a slightly musky cucumber water. It's an extremely simplistic profile. I expected a ginger bomb, but got an uninspiring airy aquatic instead. Kind of smells like a pool-side (but without too much chlorine in it). For some reason, my wife ADORES it, but she can't describe why. I find it to be more of a body mist profile than a real fragrance.
The differences: Mule's aquatic airy notes are slightly better quality. In Lunar, these notes are a little more synthetic, and come off a tiny bit "eggy". Otherwise, they're very similar. They perform the same too.
Subjective Scent Score: 6.8 (wife 9.1). It has no "bite". Not sweet, not fruity, not spicy... Just a "nothing fragrance".
On skin (longevity): Both 5-6 hours.
Performance above skin: Both low-medium projection for about an hour, then low scent bubble for another 1-2 hours. Skin scent at hour 3.
Blind buy safety score: 8.8. Very inoffensive and basic. No one is going to complain when you wear it. Great for people who want a super subtle scent, like ones working closely with patients, or ones not allowed to wear fragrances to work.
Unisex Score (0=fem, 5=unisex, 10=Male): 6.0.
Versatility Score: 7.0. Summer-spring only, mostly daytime... But any and every occasion.
Blend Quality Score: Mule 7.1 (average clone quality), Lunar 6.8 (slightly below average clone quality).
Value Score: Lunar 7.0 $24 (Jomashop) for below average quality and below performance. Mule 5.5. $34 (FragranceNet) for average quality and below average performance.
Should cost: Lunar $12-$15. Mule $20-$25.
Bottle design: Lunar 7.5. Mule 9.0.
Atomizer Score:N/A
Conclusion: I'm not interested in getting either of these. But if you're worried about sticking out in the crowd, this one is for you.
And as always, don't trust me, get decants!