Isn't it fun when a shy person just gets more and more attractive as they get comfortable around you?
I just like it. I (30mtf) recently met a girl (25mtf) who at first I found a bit too awkward for my regular tastes, but I saw a certain charm in her that captivated me (a certain je ne sais quoi plus she's really quite pretty) and now I think I'm actually pretty into her after seeing her a few times.
At first I was like "she's cute and seems sweet but idk if this is in serious consideration for me"; too awkward, too reserved, too dorky af for my "usual" tastes. I tend to gravitate towards someone a bit more extroverted and lively. But she has very quickly proven to be a very earnest, adventurous, passionate person with a lot of soul and wit. I detect no irony about anything she does and she's clearly self-aware about her own mega-dorkazoid tendencies. She's fully uncompromising and I'm just finding myself more and more attracted to her every time I see her. She's no longer reserved around me either; now she's just pure autistic rizz.
She's shown me more of herself as she's gotten more comfortable and I like what I see, and I'm glad I gave her a chance. I like the trajectory this has taken.
Feel free to share any stories you may have of cute shy people, or how you took a chance on someone you didn't think was your type but you ended up being into them anyway.