Question about Act X of 1947 / citizenship loss for expelled ethnic Germans (minor child case)
So I just received a response from Budapest today. I hadn’t heard anything in almost 9 months after my verification of citizenship meeting.
Out of the blue they denied Hungarian citizenship verification application by descent, and I’m waiting on the formal legal reasoning from Budapest.
Based on the wording from the consulate, I suspect they may argue that my grandfather lost Hungarian citizenship under postwar legislation affecting ethnic Germans (possibly Act X of 1947 or related laws).
I’m trying to understand how this would legally apply to a case like his.
Facts:
Grandfather born in Hungary: 29 November 1932
Ethnic German family from Hungary
Expelled/forcibly relocated to Soviet-controlled Germany in 1947, before his 15th birthday (so age 14)
He did not voluntarily move to Germany
As far as I know, he never acquired East German/German citizenship
Later records continued to identify him as Hungarian, including:
IRO / Arolsen refugee-emigration records (1951)
U.S. immigration records (1951)
U.S. naturalization documents (1957)
My questions:
If Budapest cites Act X of 1947 (or related postwar citizenship laws), would those provisions automatically have applied to a 14-year-old minor expelled with his family?
Did these laws automatically terminate citizenship, or were some of them primarily about expulsion/property/confiscation?
Would forced relocation to Soviet-controlled Germany by itself have caused loss of Hungarian citizenship, even if the person later continued to be documented internationally as Hungarian and apparently never became German?
Is there any historical/legal distinction for minor children expelled with their parents?
I’m hoping to appeal the decision and just trying to understand everything in the process.