u/MintmanSupreme

Thanks sensei

Since we’ve analyzed literally every character at this point even though we have gotten some pretty definitive answers on the subject, let’s keep beating this dead horse. Some important clues to notice that agent Milton could have been the Van Der Linde gangs rat are:

If you pay attention closely, you may notice whenever Agent Milton is shown in the game usually chaos with the law follows. This could be due to him giving information to the feds, Pinkertons and the local police.

You may often notice the gang members seem uneasy around him, like perhaps a 6th sense for his treachery. They will often subtly reach for their weapons or abandon the camp when he is near.

Lastly Agent Milton tells Arthur that Micah was the rat. How would he know that unless he was also a rat?

Let me know what you think of this theory. I don’t personally believe it, but i just wanted to discus.