Visa gift cards are a great idea.... if you hate the person.
Visa gift cards are better than they used to be, but Heidi thinks they're still a garbage gift.
She tested the only two options in Canada: the Vanilla Prepaid Visa, and the Joker Prepaid Visa.
Both worked for basic purchases, but the fees and restrictions were not worth it. The $20 Vanilla card had a $7.95 activation fee (not including tax), which is almost 40% of the card’s value. That means you pay nearly $28 so your recipient can spend a measly $20.
Nor can these cards do everything a regular Visa can do. You generally cannot use them for recurring bills, pre-authorized payments, or cash withdrawals. And they're not reloadable.
Vanilla also clearly says it cannot be used for pay-at-the-pump gas purchases. Joker has similar restrictions, and some online retailers may decline it unless you pay an optional $2.50 verification fee.
It's also hard to use up the full balance. If your purchase is more than what’s left on the card, you have to ask for a split-tender transaction. Tell the cashier the exact amount left on the gift card first, then pay the rest another way.
Vanilla is probably the better pick if you must buy one, because it has slightly cheaper fees and clearer restrictions. Joker may be a little more flexible, especially because it offers cardholder verification and possibly more online acceptance, but that costs extra.
Heidi says don’t buy these as gifts unless you have a very specific reason. Cash, an e-Transfer, or a gift card to a store the person actually likes is the way to go.
Or, y'know, engage in some basic human interaction and get something relevant to their interests 🤯