Why Does Italian-American Culture Seem To be Stronger and More Vibrant in Places such as New York, New Jersey, Boston, Philly and Chicago compared to other areas?
Disclaimer: These aren't the only areas with vibrant Italian-American culture just the ones I thought of immediately.
I'm part Italian from Michigan. While Michigan no doubt has a stronger Italian influence (Detroit style Pizza, Mike Modano), it never seemed to be that strong of a culture here. Polish a bit (I'm part Polish and Indian, with a Polish surname), but most Italians just consider themselves white American and don't make a big deal of it. People really don't brag about being Italian. I don't see a ton of Italian flags. But when I've visited places like NYC, New Jersey, Boston, Philly and Chicago, being Italian in those areas is a big deal. People really love and embrace their Italian Heritage. When I visited those areas, despite my polish surname. I often get mistaken for being full Italian (or Hispanic) likely due to my Italian-Indian mix. But people thought it was cool that I was Italian and it was a big deal to them.
Of course, we see similar things on tv shows such as The Sopranos and movies like Goodfellas or A Bronx Tale.
I'm in Florida right now. I've been here for a long time. A lot of Italian-Americans here. But kind of like Michigan, no one seems to make a big deal of it. Most even with Italian surnames, just consider themselves white American. I've spent time in Georgia and it was largely the samething. They really didn't see themselves as Italian-American. Just White American with some Italian ancestry.
This isn't meant to be a hate or a criticism. I love my Italian-American heritage. I just find it fascinating that in some areas people tend to embrace their ancestry more as where others people don't care as much. If anything, I wonder why Italian-Americans in other areas don't embrace it as much?