
Reincarnation is incompatible with Atman/Brahman
Okay, Hindu friends, hear me out.
I'm currently reading the principal Upanishads (just finished reading the Katha) and I realized something.
Correct me if I get any of this wrong, because I'm honestly trying to understand.
A core belief running through Hinduism is that reality is born of the consciousness of Brahman. Our individuated consciousness -- jivatman -- is an illusion; it's really just an expression of the true, shared self (Atman) which is, in turn, an aspect of Brahman.
Fine. I totally get that.
A second core belief is that individuals who do not attain enlightenment are going to be reincarnated, while those that do are "embraced by Brahman" and become one with this Source.
But if jivatman is an illusion, then what exactly is being reincarnated?
See what I'm getting at? There's no self there to reincarnate.
Either it was all Brahman, the whole time, and the separate self doesn't exist, or the self is separate after all, and can be reincarnated.
So which is it?