A friend asked me to proofread a manuscript, and it’s fully bot generated
For context, I’m a published author in my country, with literary awards and nominations and I’ve been writing for almost 25 years, with several (non-commercially) published novels and novellas and two commercially published novels. One thing about my craft, I will NEVER use GenAI in my work, not even to find meanings of words (Merriam-Webster is there) or for cover arts (I commission art from small and upcoming artists or just use Canva ) I do enjoy helping other authors to write and publish, and do proofreading and beta reading for free.
Just today a friend reached out with a novel written by her brother, inquiring about publishing and she shared the manuscript with me. I open it, and the start seems okay. But then I see those one liner scripts of GenAI, the soulless writing you see on social media captions and such. You know, like:
“It’s cold.
Not like the refrigerator
Not like in the Arctics
Like pins in your eyes”
(I didn’t take from the manuscript here or use AI, I just made up the above lines)
I have already agreed to proofread but I feel a headache coming every time I open the manuscript. It’s the same one liner script over and over and over again, vomited across the pages. How is that writing? As someone who’s spent hours over the computer, carefully crafting my work, writing well and writing badly, struggling with writer’s block and taking months to emotionally recover, that manuscript is a slap on my face. And one day, that author might publish that book. He’d call himself an author. What does that mean for me? I’m so angry and upset, and I don’t know if I’m going to address this with the person who generated the manuscript or keep my mouth shut.