u/Odd_Inspection_8210

Looking for POD supplier recommendations for caps/hats and bags

I currently sell on Etsy and I'm looking for a reliable print-on-demand supplier specifically for caps/hats and bags.

What I need:

• No minimum orders or stock holding

• Direct fulfilment to customers

• Etsy integration/automated fulfilment ideally

• Selling mainly to both the USA and UK - Worldwide is a bonus

• Fast production and shipping, ideally delivered within 5–10 business days

• Good selection of caps, especially pink baseball caps, dad caps or trucker caps

• Printing/DTF is absolutely fine, it doesn't need to be embroidery

• Bags such as drawstring/gym bags, totes and similar accessories

• Reasonable product + shipping costs that leave enough margin for Etsy

I've already looked at Printify, Printful, Gelato, PrintKK, PrintDoors, InterestPrint, PeaPrint, Merchize and a few others.

The cheaper suppliers I've found tend to have 10–20+ business day delivery, while the faster suppliers can get very expensive.

Has anyone found a POD supplier that hits the sweet spot of good prices + fast USA/UK fulfilment for caps and bags?

Would I be best finding a UK POD for one listing and a USA one and make another listing?

Would especially love recommendations from people who have actually ordered from the supplier recently.

Hi everyone!! :)

I've been working on my Etsy shop for a few months and would really appreciate some honest feedback from experienced sellers.

My niche is print-on-demand apparel and accessories aimed at wrestling fans, gym culture and fitness. I've made around 30 sales so far, but traffic has been much slower than I'd hoped and I'm trying to work out what I should prioritise next.

I'm not looking for people to buy anything, just genuine constructive criticism.

I'd really appreciate feedback on things like:

• First impression of the shop
• Branding and whether it feels consistent
• Product photos and thumbnails
• SEO, titles and tags
• Pricing
• Anything that would stop you buying
• Anything that looks confusing or could be improved

1. What inspired you to create this shop?

I've always loved wrestling, fitness and motivational designs, but I struggled to find apparel that reflected that community without using official branding or generic slogans. I wanted to create original designs that capture the energy, confidence and identity of wrestling fans and gym-goers. My aim is to build a recognisable brand that people wear because it represents who they are, not just because they need another T-shirt.

1. What research have you already done on your shop prior to opening? What is something you learned from that research?

Before opening, I researched successful Etsy shops, Etsy search trends, competitor listings, Printify products and pricing, and buyer search behaviour using Etsy search suggestions, Google, Reddit and social media.

I've spent a lot of time trying to improve the shop, so I'd really value fresh eyes from people who know Etsy.

Shop: https://www.etsy.com/uk/shop/FreeSpiritEdit https://FreeSpiritEdit.etsy.com

Thanks in advance. I promise I can take honest feedback!