Am I the only one who thinks we’re about to massively overrate rookie QBs again?
Every offseason I convince myself fans/media learned the lesson about rookie QB expectations and then training camp starts and everybody’s talking themselves into immediate superstardom again.
Feels like it’s already happening with this draft class.
I saw people talking about certain rookies like if they’re not top-12 QBs by December it’s a disappointment. Meanwhile most successful NFL QBs historically looked messy as rookies.
Even guys who became elite:
Josh Allen was raw
Peyton led the league in INTs
Trevor looked rough Year 1
Stroud honestly might’ve broken people’s brains because now everyone expects instant success
Especially now that defenses are getting more disguised and complex every year.
I actually think “competent starter with flashes” should be considered a really good rookie season, but online discourse makes it feel like if a rookie isn’t carrying a playoff push immediately he’s labeled a bust.
Wondering where other fans are at on this because draft season always feels like expectation inflation.