u/RichIndependence8930

Why so many Reapers have been downed in Iran, an analysis.

Why so many Reapers have been downed in Iran, an analysis.

The 24 reapers imo are the most tactically impactful because that platform is what the USA was probably nearly exclusively using to go TEL hunting. The US had strong air superiority over Iran, but they still seemingly had a network of short-medium range air defenses operating mostly using infrared and optical (or both) guidance. I think that, paired with the dust/haze/rain, made the USA decide that it was safer to make a Reaper toss laser guided munitions instead of a manned aircraft since using laser guided munitions in non-favorable conditions can greatly impact their performance, namely in the way that the targeting pod simply has to be closer to the target to get an accurate hit.

So something guiding an LGM would have to be say, only 5-10 miles away from its target instead of 15 miles or more. Which is pretty risky to get a manned craft to do unless you are up against an opponent that has no way of hitting said loitering manned aircraft that might be operating at 20k feet and 10 miles away from its target instead of 40k feet and 20 miles away from its target because of the dust/fog/rain/haze.

Another factor is the actual cloud ceiling itself. If its dusty/hazy/cloudy etc from 10k feet to 30k feet, the Reapers might be "forced" to operate below 10k feet to get a good paint on the target with the pod laser.

The USA did not know when Iran would be launching, a key factor in this I believe. So they stationed reapers to loiter and catch the TELs once they were exposed.

I think most manned craft in Iran were more or less tossing JDAM ERs or BLU's from 50k feet or so well outside of the range of most of Irans short to medium range air defenses. The reapers were the ones doing the TEL hunting by and large loitering around the missile cities for hours on end.

So if Iran can keep downing the reapers (not in production anymore) they can save their TELs a good bit of trouble.

To add to this, Iran has a passive radar system called the Alim

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alim_radar_system

That is probably being greatly used (along with electronic receivers) for search duty, more or less gathering location data to triangulate the location and even height of aircraft over their skies. A dozen or so Alims, paired with electronic receivers across Iran, would be a pretty good way to triangulate the location of things in their skies.

And if you are the IRGC, you are going to assume any jets in your skies are enemy jets. The 318 loitering missile imo is trained to track any and all exhaust and any jets optically, there is no need to have it trained to distinguish an F35 from an F18 or an SU24 from an F18, Iran knew their skies would be pretty much solely populated by US/Israeli aircraft in any major war with them. So that probably saved that program a good bit of work.

Its overall an EW suite that is very catered to fighting against the USA, who wants to send a HARM at anything they can

▲ 32 r/war

Hezbollah targeted and presumably hit an Iron Dome launcher with an FPV between March 18-19th.

▲ 291 r/war+1 crossposts

Israel reportedly killed a Bedouin civilian who had stumbled upon a hidden Israeli airbase in Iraq in order to prevent the location from being leaked.

nytimes.com
u/AlbinoAkon — 2 days ago

How much does the Shahed-136 really cost to make?

Articles and analysis range from 7k-10k USD to all the way to 70k. The following articles argue for the lower end of the price.

https://legrandcontinent.eu/es/2026/03/14/el-coste-real-de-produccion-de-un-dron-shahed-136-podria-rondar-los-3-500-euros/ (main write up, but paywalled)

https://ca.news.yahoo.com/iran-shahed-drones-reshaping-economics-071404927.html?guccounter=1 (pretty much situates its arguments on the above paywalled article)

https://www.rfi.fr/fr/podcasts/aujourd-hui-l-%C3%A9conomie/20260319-pourquoi-les-drones-iraniens-shahed-136-co%C3%BBtent-cinq-fois-moins-cher-que-les-drones-am%C3%A9ricains

https://www.tehrantimes.com/print/521986/US-faces-flak-at-home-for-testing-copy-of-Iranian-drone (Iranian source)

The key differentiator in price seems to be how much Iran is paying for certain components and what components are going into certain drones, and their domestic industry costs and efficiency due to time in production. Jam resistant components are higher price, of course. Optical guidance paired with GPS guidance will also increase the price.

There is another argument made by these articles and similar ones that claim the Western analysis is confusing cost for a Russian produced Geranium 2 (Shahed-136 more or less) for the cost to produce a Shahed 136 within Iran.

So what I am figuring is, the price for Iran to produce a Shahed 136 depends greatly on whether or not you believe they are struggling hard to gain access to certain components. The sanctions play a role here, but so does Russia in negating the effect of said sanctions. Russia has a lot of domestic manufacturing specifically for drone components. Also, the basic Shahed 136 devoid of jamming resistant equipment or optical sensors is pretty much entirely made with off the shelf components.

The fiberglass body, lawnmower engine, and explosives used in the Shahed are a fraction of the cost, undoubtedly. So whether one is to believe the IRGC can make a Shahed 136 for 10k or not depends on whether or not you believe Russia/China are able to fulfill certain orders to a price that analysts are either not putting credence into or not taking into account.

So overall, the arguments for higher price per unit (20-50k) are more or less entirely down to sanctions. The arguments for a lower price are more or less entirely down to said sanctions not being able to inhibit Iran enough from procuring components from Russia.

Iran's drone production is very mature and streamlined. They, unlike Ukraine especially, nearly exclusively produce one kind of one way suicide drone, the Shahed 136. And have been doing so for over a decade. Its a very mature program and very mature supply/production chain. They also have much lower wages than Russia does for their manufacturing sector.

The USA was able to produce about 200 LUCAS drones for 35k a pop. The USA is a far higher profit-orientated MIC with much higher wages for workers in said production and development. To me, the claims that Iran cannot produce a Shahed 136 (base model, no jamming resistant components and no optical guidance) for less than 35k are bordering non-credible. I think there are just as many arguments to be made that favor them being able to produce them for 10-15k as there are that claim they cost 30-50k.

Thoughts?

u/RichIndependence8930 — 7 days ago
▲ 6 r/war

Is Hezbollah footage no longer allowed?

I am still seeing them post footage of new strikes on other platforms like X and TG. But no one is uploading the stuff here or on r/combatfootage. They are a DTO, so technically the footage isn't allowed. anyone know?

Edit to say, pretty sure they did. All Hezbollah footage on v.reddit is "removed by reddits filters". Ah well, keep the echo chamber going I guess

reddit.com
u/RichIndependence8930 — 9 days ago
▲ 18 r/oil

The similarities between the current energy/fertilizer crisis and vascular capillary disease/damage.

When blood flow is limited in the body due to whatever reason, the smaller capillaries far away from the heart and torso are what dies first. That is the way I think about the current crisis. The big organs can always get their blood, unless the body is more or less dumping its carotid onto the floor somewhere. But the small capillaries (read: poor countries with weak currencies and no energy/fertilizer independence) closer to the extremities are the ones that fold up and die first. That is more or less where this crisis is as of right now. The big organs are not having an ideal time (the big, rich countries with energy/fertilizer independence or enough of it) but they are surviving pretty well. The small capillaries feeding the digits of the hand and such are the ones really struggling right now.

reddit.com
u/RichIndependence8930 — 14 days ago

I am trying to transport villagers and I've literally acquired 1000 cobble stone in a John Henry esque performance tunneling through a mountain. I want the water to flow nicely but its somehow, within 8 blocks, flowing in 4 different directions.

reddit.com
u/RichIndependence8930 — 15 days ago
▲ 33 r/war

"Based on the request of Pakistan and other Countries, the tremendous Military Success that we have had during the Campaign against the Country of Iran and, additionally, the fact that Great Progress has been made toward a Complete and Final Agreement with Representatives of Iran, we have mutually agreed that, while the Blockade will remain in full force and effect, Project Freedom (The Movement of Ships through the Strait of Hormuz) will be paused for a short period of time to see whether or not the Agreement can be finalized and signed. President DONALD J. TRUMP"

I do wonder if this is happening because keeping destroyers operating near Iran's coast long term was deemed too risky/expensive. Those SM-3/6s ain't cheap and plentiful.

truthsocial.com
u/RichIndependence8930 — 17 days ago
▲ 24 r/LessCredibleDefence+1 crossposts

Let's see how well the interceptor rationing goes. If they are planning on staying in the Gulf, they will potentially have to deal with assaults every day without a capacity to restock due to a lot of the bases in the area being out of operation.

Also, the US Navy still has no restock at sea capacity for those big ass SM series interceptors.

u/RichIndependence8930 — 17 days ago

Lost a cat to lava. Literally teleported over it when I went too far and it caught up. Lost another cat because it ran off a cliff. Lost 2 dogs the same way.

What the hell? I feel like the coding pathfinding should be able to detect lava or falls around the pet, and just like...not teleport it/direct it over those areas.

Like are they literally just a cosmetic CPU hog? The freaking Ghast is useless too because it moves so damn slow. The only useful pets to me so far are horses and nautiluses.

reddit.com
u/RichIndependence8930 — 22 days ago

You know what I am talking about. The first two books had a decent enough amount to make me cringe pretty hard sometimes, how bad are the two Endymion books?

reddit.com
u/RichIndependence8930 — 23 days ago
▲ 7 r/oil

2008 saw a rise in crude, and a rise in LNG and fertilizer that crashed pretty quickly while crude stayed up.

This situation is fundamentally different due to the blockage of all hydrocarbon products as well as crude and LNG. Yes, crude was expensive back in 2008. But that was really the worst of it. Now, crude is not only expensive, but fertilizer and natural gas are too. And it can get worse, so much worse price wise. If you are an African, or Latin American, or SEA country you will struggle very very hard to get sufficient access to things because your currency just cannot compete with others who will be doing the same thing.

The Hormuz is blocked right now. It happened so quickly no one could prepare. 2008 was not a physical blockage, and there was time to prepare.

This can easily get way worse than 2008.

reddit.com
u/RichIndependence8930 — 23 days ago
▲ 7 r/war

BTW, this Ukrainian unit who filmed this literally has a Sonnenrad as their unit emblem. Top right. Yeesh.

u/RichIndependence8930 — 24 days ago