Image 1 — 9 Michelin Star Day - Breakfast at SingleThread ***, Lunch at Quince ***, Dinner at Benu ***
Image 2 — 9 Michelin Star Day - Breakfast at SingleThread ***, Lunch at Quince ***, Dinner at Benu ***
Image 3 — 9 Michelin Star Day - Breakfast at SingleThread ***, Lunch at Quince ***, Dinner at Benu ***
Image 4 — 9 Michelin Star Day - Breakfast at SingleThread ***, Lunch at Quince ***, Dinner at Benu ***
Image 5 — 9 Michelin Star Day - Breakfast at SingleThread ***, Lunch at Quince ***, Dinner at Benu ***
▲ 368 r/MichelinStars+1 crossposts

9 Michelin Star Day - Breakfast at SingleThread ***, Lunch at Quince ***, Dinner at Benu ***

As far as 3 stars we've tried. We would rate our experiences as:

SingleThread breakfast - 8/10 (10/10 for the inn room itself)

We both had each the japanese breakfast and sonoma breakfast on separate days. I preferred the sonoma breakfast and the amazing egg souffle. From the japanese breakfast the salmon and the rice were each really delicious and I would love to have them again.

Quince Lunch - 10/10

Quince was the standout, everything was so delicious, the beetroot spaghetti with caviar was one of the best dishes of the trip. The bread was great, and it was perfect to dip in all the sauces of the dishes. The cheese board was incredible as well, a lot of unique and delicious cheese flavors.

Benu Dinner - 7/10

Everything at Benu was technically excellent, but we found overselves thinking its not food we really want to eat again and again if given the chance. As a one time novelty it was good but its not the kind of food we find the most delicious so much as just technically impressive.

French Laundry Bonus Bites

On another day of the trip, we got to stop at The French Laundry as well, while we didn't do a sit down service, we had a special experience with a private group event where the restaurant was wide open from the kitchen to the wine cellar to stroll around in and have wine and hangout. Thomas Keller was there and walking around and chatting with everyone, and at various stations there was a buffet style layout of dishes coming out fresh constantly and you could grab repeats of anything you wanted. There were extras of each dish after everyone got full. Everything there was incredible, every bite was so flavorful. The salmon cone, and the ice cream desert stood out to me. The ice cream dessert was one of the most unique, pleasingly less sweet ice creams I've had. I didn't get enough pictures there but did grab a few.

u/Sea_Physics401 — 11 days ago

I'm planning a special romatinc event, and will be in Manhattan for two weeks around Christmas and NYE and will be there for both holidays. Would love to hear thoughts from those who have been and can compare them for me.

Im weighing these hotel and room options:

  1. Baccarat Hotel - One Bedroom Suite at - 800 sq ft ~ $42k all in, ~3k/night

  2. Aman New York - 500-500 sq ft ~$56k all in, ~$4k/night

  3. Greenwhich Hotel - Studio Suite - 650sqft ~$42k all in, ~3k/night (estimate, exact quote not available yet)

I've narrowed down to these 3 hotels because they each have their own distinc apeal to me,

Baccarat - love the vibe from the pictures, seems like the right high galmour celeabration type place for the trip. Also they have a really strong spa, and the suite sq footage/price relative to the other options is great. near the park

Aman - would be excited about the service and the spa, near the park. And im sure its gorgeous inside but in a modern modern/minimal aesthetic. Would be first time at an Aman.

Greenwhich - I've read great things, the in suite sauna is a huge plus, the nieghborhood is a lot more chill

I've gotten here by process of elimination of a lot of other hotels,, some quickly:

- The Whitby - Love it a lot, but for this two week stay prefer a hotel with a spa and the whitby doesnt have one

- Crosby - no spa / sauna

- Four Seasons - The price on our dates is a lot higher than the rest of the options and I cant see it being worth it going up against Aman, and Greenwhich for this trip

- Cipriani - Want to be more north

- Pendy - Like it, but corporate/sterile / not romantic enoguh for this trip

reddit.com
u/Sea_Physics401 — 2 months ago