What makes you regard a peice of fantasy writing as "serious"

Is it the prose or the subject matter presented in the first chapter or even page of a fantasy that makes novels like Dune, LOTR, GOT, and those others so popular? Or is it that they are old and written long ago, so it suddenly gives them literary weight?

Can very serious subject matters come later but still appeal to the audiences of these works? What constitutes a dark or epic fantasy on its very first page?

I could research this, obviously, but I just want to hear some other opinions.

I'm not sure if the way I've worded it makes sense, but first chapters are hard to nail, and I wonder what kept people reading the novels I listed, and/or what makes the opening of a novel feel like a true dark and epic fantasy.

reddit.com
u/Seretdoesntknow — 1 day ago

A Hell Awaits (Dark Fantasy, 2028 words)

I'm still getting a hang of prose, structure, and many, many, many other things, but some feedback would be greatly appreciated.

I feel like I, as a writer, should be able to pinpoint what is wrong, but I still struggle with it. I have a lot of doubts, but I am still learning. Before I go on, I want to see what I need to fix, improve on, and more.

Would you keep reading? Are you invested enough in the character? How big or small does the world feel? This is a very early first draft, so a lot is bound to change; however, I want to escape the juvenile writing, story, plot, etc.

I often scrap my first chapters due to fear of them feeling too small, too much, or not epic enough for the genre I claim it is. But other perspectives may help! Thank you!

u/Seretdoesntknow — 8 days ago
▲ 1 r/CSULB

PSY 100-03 last minute online

Is anyone taking PSY 100-03 Lec? At first it showed it was in person Tuesday Thursday, now it’s online and the days are TBA. Does anyone know why?

reddit.com
u/Seretdoesntknow — 9 days ago
▲ 2 r/fantasywriting+1 crossposts

A background, a main focus, and a worldbuilding dynamic. Is it too much?

I’m writing a chapter and I’ve noticed that my background seems to dull out what i want the chapter to mainly focus on.
Think of this background like it’s rain.

That’s just an example. It’s raining, it’s causing a disturbance in the protagonist’s world, the protagonist pauses to observe while on the way to the main event of the chapter, the main focus has little to do with what’s currently happening in the background, but it still can’t be ignored because the background will have importance latter

unless it’s advised I just push it to another chapter. Again it’s just an example not what I’m actually writing.

Usually chapters focus on one main thing, don’t they? I just worry this would feel like too much happening at once, unless I’m just at a stage where I’m over thinking.

reddit.com
u/Seretdoesntknow — 2 months ago

Question, does it read as lazy or overdone if a story is opened to a character being called to answer to a higher power’s command. This command will lead the protagonist to the inciting incident
But not too sure how to go about it without that opening.

reddit.com
u/Seretdoesntknow — 4 months ago

What’s a sequence of event you’ve noticed in fantasy novel’s and their first chapter that seems overdone. Or is there no such thing and it doesn’t really matter?

reddit.com
u/Seretdoesntknow — 4 months ago