Headcanons: Little Witches as Girlfriends Part 2:
Again, this is after they graduate and are mid-20's
Diana: Perfect, Prissy, Prudish Princess. Congratulations! You've somehow pulled Luna Nova's supermodel. Until you get home. Turns out, she's exhausted from the attention and just wants to wear sweatpants, one of your oversized t-shirts, and eat ice cream. Naturally, this is the cutest thing in the world.
Hannah: She's a bit of an... acquired taste. She's mellowed out but is still a mean bully deep down. But this extends to either: 1) Doing damage control while she picks a fight. Or 2) joining her in throwing hands on a creep. She's also, weirdly, kind of like a cat and is super cuddly until she tells you to piss off.
Barbara: She's my favorite, so I'll keep this brief. Otherwise, it'd be six paragraphs. She's a calm and supportive member of the community but is still pretty shy. On dates, she lets you do the talking. At home, she will grab you by the neck and tell you about her newest obsession. Amusingly, counter attacks, such as hugs, deep kisses, or even gentle words, make her straight up dissociate. Think, ERROR 404 level of mind blank. Naturally, she hates that you both are the only one who knows this weakness, and the only one who can pull it off.