

I can’t wait until we’re on Disventure Camp season 25 and Gabby is having her 8th independence arc. Why I don’t like Gabby this season
I hate what they’re doing with Gabby this season especially due to the fact that it’s literally exactly what she did in DCAS. It’s clear that the writers like her, they want her to stick around, however they have no idea what to do with her. She has no interesting connections or character arcs she’s just there. And they give her moments in an attempt to get us to sympathize with her but it’s not even clear what her struggle IS. Therefore, when she puts on the trademark Disventure camp sad expression it’s hard to emphasize with her due to the fact that we know nothing about her own personal struggles beyond the fact that she’s been calling “annoying” her entire life. But it’s never explored like how every other character gets explored. Everything detail we get about Gabby is just thrown at us with little to no explanation or overall relevance to anything happening around her.
I just feel like this stems from the fact that DC writers have no clue what they want Gabby to BE. Is she “comedic” relief? Is she a character that we’re supposed to take seriously? Is she a support character for other more important characters? Or is she herself supposed to be considered a main character? What I feel COULD have worked for her this season is if they delved into her being a character that masks her pain with humor. But for some reason they gave that plot line to TOM? He’s never displayed that trait like…ever but is placed as a mirror to Natalia when really it should’ve been GABBY who should’ve been Natalia’s foil. Gabby should’ve been the one to form a friendly rivalry with Natalia. It would’ve made her far more interesting now than what we ended up getting with her because it’s in line with her actual pre-existing character and would’ve opened up for FAR more depth and nuance. Especially since the Tom vs Natalia rivalry that took up so much screen time ended on such a whimper that not even the surrounding contestant gave a fuck about what was happening.
You might be thinking, “well then what’s tom going to do?!” I’d force HIM into Gabby’s role. He’s much more suited to playing peace keeper than she is and we don’t NEED more of Tom. He’s already a three-dimensional fleshed out character whether you like him or not. Putting him in a more passive role only serves to not have people get more sour on him than they already are. Having Tom hog so much screen time having doing the same in DCAS and having his own two season show was NOT a good move. Having Gabby actually stand on her own two feet against Natalia is vastly more interesting to me.
But instead of getting a compelling storyline about facing her past trauma and helping someone with the same coping mechanisms as her she’s being forced into a passive role that she’s NEVER been in before. Even at her worst Gabby has always at least been an active player making her own choices. But in fvf she’s just stuck in the middle of some lackluster friendship between Tom and Natalia. She’s not allowed to have any interesting and complex thoughts on anything happening around her. All she says is “let’s be friends guys!” And that’s the extent of her role in that plot. She just sits around and meanders while Tom and Natalia figure out their shit.
And even now she’s claiming that she’s “playing her own game” but she’s just doing whatever anyone TELLS her to do. Yet another example of this season forcing Gabby to be a passive character when she’s not BUILT for that role. Gabby is and has always been the chaotic neutral Character. She’s always been an active player in the game. In DC1 it was HER who decided to use her idol to save Ellie, SHE had a rivalry with Dan (whether you liked it or not). In DCAS SHE was the one who flipped to the villains alliance, it was GABBY who made the move to eliminate Tess, it was HER who decided she was going to help Grett no matter what. And yet her depiction in FvF shows her as a passive crybaby who does nothing but what people TELL her to do. That’s why I hate this new “Gabby Independence” arc because that’s not what it is. She’s had this same arc in DCAS and it was surprisingly executed far better than whatever is going on in this season.
It’s shocking how far she’s made it because she’s done nothing to deserve making it as far as she has. She’s made no game moves, have no interesting connections, no character arc besides stop being judgy ig???, and yet she’s still here. Just AROUND. And this isn’t meant to hate on Gabby or anyone who likes her this is just how I personally feel towards her this season.
TLDR; Gabby is being forced into a passive role when she’s never been in that role before and being passive contradicts her entire pre-existing character.