After the death of Muhammad but before widespread availability of written copies of the Quran and before the widespread establishment of local Islamic authorities, what was "Islam" in practice to early Muslims (if they didn't necessarily have the whole text or some local authority)?

After the death of Muhammad but before widespread availability of written copies of the Quran and before the widespread establishment of local Islamic authorities, what was "Islam" in practice to early Muslims (if they didn't necessarily have the whole text or some local authority)?

After the death of Muhammad but before widespread availability of written copies of the Quran and before the widespread establishment of local Islamic authorities, what was "Islam" in practice to early Muslims (if they didn't necessarily have the whole text or some local authority)?

u/TeluguFilmFile — 5 days ago

Based on the Quran alone (and without using any Hadiths etc.), what according to Quran are the core differences between Jews, Christians (i.e., those who worship Jesus as incarnation of God), and the Believers (i.e., those who accept Muhammad as the final Prophet and follow what he preached)?

Based on the Quran alone (and without using any Hadiths etc.), what according to Quran are the core differences between Jews, Christians (i.e., those who worship Jesus as incarnation of God), and the Believers (i.e., those who accept Muhammad as the final Prophet and follow what he preached)?

u/TeluguFilmFile — 6 days ago

Why do these girls take these kinds of pictures with the Kaamaandhudu? Do they know about his history?

Why do these girls take these kinds of pictures with the Kaamaandhudu? Do they know about his history?

u/TeluguFilmFile — 13 days ago

What are the earliest Arabian Islamic retellings (by Muslims) of the life and teachings/message of Jesus? Did earliest Muslims care equally about all prophets? Or were earlier prophets effectively irrelevant for them because they perhaps viewed Muhammad as conveying the entirety of the teachings?

What are the earliest Arabian Islamic retellings (by Muslims) of the life and teachings/message of Jesus? Did earliest Muslims care equally about all prophets? Or were earlier prophets effectively irrelevant for them because they perhaps viewed Muhammad as conveying the entirety of the teachings?

u/TeluguFilmFile — 14 days ago

Is there any historicity to the story of Muhammad's extramarital affair with Coptic slave Mariyah? Was this story made up to justify a Quranic verse, or did Muhammad really have slaves with whom he had extramarital affairs? What is the context of the relevant Quranic verses (if they're related)?

Is there any historicity to the story of Muhammad's extramarital affair with Coptic slave Mariyah? Was this story made up to justify a Quranic verse, or did Muhammad really have slaves with whom he had extramarital affairs? What is the context of the relevant Quranic verses (if they're related)?

youtube.com
u/TeluguFilmFile — 18 days ago
▲ 30 r/MalayalamMovies+1 crossposts

I am glad they picked Vijay Yesudas for the "O Sundari" song in "Rao Bahadur." Perfect choice. He literally inherited the voice of his father K. J. Yesudas.

I am glad they picked Vijay Yesudas for the "O Sundari" song in "Rao Bahadur." Perfect choice. He literally inherited the voice of his father K. J. Yesudas.

youtube.com
u/TeluguFilmFile — 23 days ago

According to the Quran, are the houris only for Muslim men who reach paradise? Or are the houris also for Muslim women who reach paradise? If so, what would houris do for the women versus men? If not, what (if anything) would the Muslim women get in paradise as per the Quran? What is a houri's role?

According to the Quran, are the houris only for Muslim men who reach paradise? Or are the houris also for Muslim women who reach paradise? If so, what would houris do for the women versus men? If not, what (if anything) would the Muslim women get in paradise as per the Quran? What is a houri's role?

u/TeluguFilmFile — 29 days ago

Does anyone know anything about the film "Heartbeat Of Shabara" and when it's getting released? Looks a bit interesting.

Does anyone know anything about the film "Heartbeat Of Shabara" and when it's getting released? Looks a bit interesting.

youtube.com
u/TeluguFilmFile — 29 days ago

Dr. Little's research suggests that some Muslims with (religious/political) authority were able to fabricate hadiths in the 8th century. Why is it or isn't it plausible that some Muslim authorities of late 7th century didn't do such a thing for (some of) materials that became part of Uthmanic codex?

Dr. Little's research suggests that some Muslims with (religious/political) authority were able to fabricate hadiths in the 8th century. Why is it or isn't it plausible that some Muslim authorities of late 7th century didn't do such a thing for (some of) materials that became part of Uthmanic codex?

reddit.com
u/TeluguFilmFile — 1 month ago
▲ 10 r/imax

Why did The Odyssey premiere at Odeon Luxe Leicester Square in London rather than BFI IMAX?

Why did The Odyssey premiere at Odeon Luxe Leicester Square in London rather than BFI IMAX?

reddit.com
u/TeluguFilmFile — 1 month ago

What is the textual history and scriptural purpose of parts of Hadiths like Sahih al-Bukhari 6:298 (about "Fondling a Menstruating Wife")? How could they have originated? How could people have believed that Aisha narrated very personal details in order for it to be included in the Hadith collection?

Sahih al-Bukhari 6:298 says, "Narrated `Aisha:
The Prophet (ﷺ) and I used to take a bath from a single pot while we were Junub. During the menses, he used to order me to put on an Izar (dress worn below the waist) and used to fondle me. While in I`tikaf, he used to bring his head near me and I would wash it while I used to be in my periods (menses)."

What is the textual history and scriptural purpose of parts of Hadiths like Sahih al-Bukhari 6:298 (about "Fondling a Menstruating Wife")? How could they have originated? How could people have believed that Aisha narrated very personal details in order for it to be included in the Hadith collection?

u/TeluguFilmFile — 1 month ago

How do academic scholars interpret, explain, and historicize the presence of contradictions (or perhaps seeming contradictions) in Hadiths such as Sahih Bukhari 157, 158, 159?

How do academic scholars interpret, explain, and historicize the presence of contradictions (or perhaps seeming contradictions) in Hadiths such as Sahih Bukhari 157, 158, 159?

u/TeluguFilmFile — 1 month ago

TV "news" is just becoming reality TV (or maybe it has always been like this). Ramanamurthy, a priest who questioned mismanagement of the Ram temple and morphing of images of deities for political purposes, was repeatedly slapped by a Telangana BJP leader with his chappal. This is political circus.

TV "news" is just becoming reality TV (or maybe it has always been like this). Ramanamurthy, a priest who questioned mismanagement of the Ram temple and morphing of images of deities for political purposes, was repeatedly slapped by a Telangana BJP leader with his chappal. This is political circus.

https://www.youtube.com/shorts/r5-IkaAuCuI

https://x.com/revathitweets/status/2077301376112267689

youtube.com
u/TeluguFilmFile — 1 month ago

I respect Nag Ashwin's artistic freedom, but why is he claiming that he's adapting the original story when he portrays Karna as rescuing Ashvatthama (when it's actually the other way around in the original story)? He should clarify he's departing from epic instead of saying, "I know what I'm doing."

I respect Nag Ashwin's artistic freedom, but why is he claiming that he's adapting the original story when he portrays Karna as rescuing Ashvatthama (when it's actually the other way around in the original story)? He should clarify he's departing from epic instead of saying, "I know what I'm doing."

It is true that in the original story/text, Krishna praises Karna's positive aspects, but in the story Karna and Arjuna and most of the main characters also have their flaws along with their positive aspects. However, the issue is that even in the 1st part of Kalki movie, Nag Ashwin doesn't highlight the flawed nature of Prabhas' character enough. There wouldn't have been the "Arjuna vs Karna" debate if Nag Ashwin had clarified that all characters have strengths and weaknesses, but that's of course not the path he chose.

Selectively quoting a text and claiming that it's the source when one departs too much from the source text is disingenuous. Maybe Nag Ashwin should "google how many times" Karna rescues Ashvatthama (directly, as portrayed in the first part of the movie, not indirectly). The answer is 0. And then he should "google how many times" Ashvatthama rescues Karna (directly or indirectly). The answer is at least 3.

Nag Ashwin claimed, "I know what I'm doing." Can he still claim that he knows what he's doing?!

u/TeluguFilmFile — 1 month ago

I think I figured out the "issue" with Rao Bahadur. Most decent movies are "one-time watch" movies; there is very little value in watch them for a second time. But Rao Bahadur is a movie that may test one's patience and disengage most on the first watch, but its value is in a "second-time" viewing.

I think I figured out the "issue" with Rao Bahadur. Most decent movies are "one-time watch" movies; there is very little value in watch them for a second time. But Rao Bahadur is a movie that may test one's patience and disengage most on the first watch, but its value is in a "second-time" viewing.

u/TeluguFilmFile — 1 month ago

Based on academic scholarship through July 2026, is there any concrete (or very reliable/plausible) evidence that Muhammad recited every single word of the Quran that is used today and was involved in the arrangement of the surahs? Or is the academic consensus that others also influenced the text?

Based on academic scholarship through July 2026, is there any concrete (or very reliable/plausible) evidence that Muhammad recited every single word of the Quran that is used today and was involved in the arrangement of the surahs? Or is the academic consensus that others also influenced the text?

u/TeluguFilmFile — 1 month ago

Rao Bahadur Review

Overall, I think people who are patient (and who enjoy world cinema rather than just the typical TFI movies) may enjoy the subtle and surreal aspects of the movie, but I think this format (and the pace) and the surreal aspects of the film are things most of the Telugu audience aren’t exposed to, so I think the film may bore most people. Having said that, this film has been the most interesting watch (among Telugu movies) for me this year so far, although I’ll say that I did feel a bit bored at certain points.

If you are willing to be patient and don’t mind experiencing something completely new (and are open to surreal elements), then just go watch the movie without any expectations. But even if you’re impatient etc, I think you may still enjoy the second half (even if you get bored during the first half).

The climax/ending is probably the best part of the movie, but the earlier parts (that may bore most people) are needed to fully understand/experience the climax, which is essentially social commentary using dark humor.

reddit.com
u/TeluguFilmFile — 2 months ago
▲ 340 r/tollywood

Don't know how Toxic is going to turn out, but Geetu Mohandas and the cinematographer of the film have clearly put in at least some effort in the visual symbolisms of various shots

Don't know how Toxic is going to turn out, but Geetu Mohandas and the cinematographer of the film have clearly put in at least some effort in the visual symbolisms of various shots

u/TeluguFilmFile — 2 months ago