u/TheSmashShane

Super Smash Bros 4. Quadrupled Roster (Comeback Vote: Final Round!)

Super Smash Bros 4. Quadrupled Roster (Comeback Vote: Final Round!)

We're at the tail end of this small contest! We have our next four winners!

Revved up and ready to rumble, Tron Bonne is back in the game!

Soaring in once again comes Garchomp!

Even though he was coldly shafted from Brawl, Jack Frost returns with an even colder vengeance!

And bouncing in once more, it's Slime!

Four more slots! Who will be our final lucky returnees on this lineup? Let's see who you choose! GAME ON!

u/TheSmashShane — 7 hours ago

Super Smash Bros 4: Quadrupled (Comeback Vote: Round 2)

Our first returnees have won the first 4 extra slots back in the game!

Banjo and Kazooie are ready for another adventure, Snake's sneaking back in for another mission, Amy's prepared to smash anyone that gets in her way, and the Famicom Detectives are back on the case!

Who will be our next lucky quartet? Let's find out and see!

Four winners will be selected going forward!

u/TheSmashShane — 2 days ago

Super Smash Bros 4 Quadrupled: (Comeback Vote: Round 1)

IT'S FINALLY TIME!!!

44 reps have been shafted from the game until Ultimate. But have they completely?

Alongside Dr. Mario, Mewtwo, Roy and Lucas, 12 more slots have opened up for our lucky returnees!

Who will take these slots?

The top three Fighters with the most votes will go on to secure their place in the 4th game! 40 Fighters, 12 spots.

Who will join our lucky quartet from before? It's up to you!

GAME ON!

u/TheSmashShane — 3 days ago

Super Smash Bros. Brawl: Quadrupled (Elimination Results)

And so, we have our final losers for Brawl.

While the roster's complete, it's clear who's getting sidelined until later.

But, don't you worry, by the next post:

IT'S FINALLY COMEBACK TIME!

So stay tuned for who you want to see make a comeback!

u/TheSmashShane — 3 days ago

Super Smash Bros. Brawl: Quadrupled (Elimination Vote: Final Round)

Oof! We have some real Heartbreakers this time folks!

Once again, Master Hand has been demoted to Boss duty!

Meanwhile, Blaze's flame has fizzle, Felix felt the ground cave beneath him, and Tron Bonne had some mechanical difficulties.

But we only have two slots remaining! Who will be our last pair of losers before the comeback vote? Let's find out for ourselves!

u/TheSmashShane — 3 days ago

Super Smash Bros. Brawl: Quadrupled (Elimination Vote: Round 4)

With a few ties added, we have a whopping six players eliminated!

Another case is closed, and the Famicom Detectives have been eliminated!

Tied with three votes are Kratos, Master Chief, Tingle and Slime. I figured Kratos and Master Chief weren't going to advance either way. And we sadly have to say a temporary goodbye to Cream and Cheese. She waited for this moment, only to have it snatched away! She needs a hug after this one!

But we're down to six slots either way! The top three votes will determine who'll be out of the running.

But remember, there is the comeback vote coming up! So there's still time to save your favorites before Smash 4 rolls around!

u/TheSmashShane — 4 days ago

Super Smash Bros Brawl: Quadrupled (Elimination Game: Round 3)

This might've been a bit of a hard one to swallow. Phanpy's sadly eliminated from this entry, Kunio's been knocked out of the game, and the case closes on Team Chaotix's run. But hopefully by the comeback vote, they won't be out for too long!

Remember, one fighter per comment only! Only the top three Fighters with the highest votes will be eliminated. Tied votes will have the other fighter be eliminated too.

u/TheSmashShane — 4 days ago

Super Smash Bros Brawl: Quadrupled (Elimination Vote: Round 2)

We have our first losers. While it's sad to see them go, their time away might not be forever! But in the meantime, here's who's sadly biting it first.

T.T's time on the battlefield has sadly run out. Maybe he can still polish off his time trials while he's cut.

Everyone can sleep more peacefully knowing that Reala's out of the game for now. What would Wizeman say about this?

And the Galactic Federation needed to call Jody for another job. So unfortunately, her schedule might not be permitted to have her return.

Who will be our next losers for this lineup? The tied vote rule still stands here. Remember, for organizational purposes, please put down the name of the fighter you want to eliminate in one comment at a time.

u/TheSmashShane — 5 days ago

Super Smash Bros Brawl: Quadrupled Roster (Elimination Game) (Round 1)

With Smash 4 around the corner, this means another round of hard cuts will have to take place. But keep in mind, even if they're gone momentarily, there's still hope for these players to get a second chance!

Remember, anyone who's in the original games are immune from being voted against! Any votes against them WILL NOT COUNT!

For the moment, we had to get rid of six Fighters from each of the three games covered. One more from the N64 game, 2 more from Melee, and three from Brawl!

The top 3 Fighters with the most votes will find themselves on the chopping block here. Anyone who ties up with the top Fighters will also sadly join them.

I know it's hard to say goodbye, but it has to be done!

Let's see who's getting cut from the competition this time.

For organizational purposes, please drop the fighter's name one at a time.

u/TheSmashShane — 5 days ago

Super Smash Bros Brawl: Quadrupled Roster (Complete!)

We have our final set of winners rounding out Brawl! I'd say this lineup looks really solid on its own right! And we've had a series of firsts occur before! But none are as crazy as this! But let's meet our last batch of winners!

In first place:

She's ready to rock and roll! Swinging in from the vines comes the DK Crew's most spunky member! The DK Crew's most energetic fighter, DIXIE KONG!!!

Tied for Second:

Combine the intimidation of a demon with the skills of a master hunter, and you have one charismatic combatant that can slay the underworld in an instant! The Hybrid Demon Hunter of Sparda, DANTE!!!

Wrapped up in an ongoing turf war, he's not afraid to let his fists do the talking! River City's Best Brawler, KUNIO!

When it comes to victory, their chances of victory seem to be stacking up! The 8-Bit Bruiser: TETROMINO!!!

Even when asleep for the past 500 years, her magic and skills never dulled against Heaven's holy messengers! The Last Surviving Umbra Witch: BAYONETTA!!!

Tied for 3rd:

Can you smell what Smash is cooking? Or is that our top Chef stepping into the fray! Can you be even better than Mama? The Kindhearted Cook herself, COOKING MAMA!!!

He has the best times on the track, but how will he measure on the battlefield? The fastest Time Trial Titan of his caliber, T.T.!

And tied for Fourth:

Many Pirates have dominated the land and sea, but one champion has the skies calling his name! The Ambitious Air Pirate of the Blue Rogues, VYSE!!!

Finally fed up with every loss, he'll take it on his own hands to bring the world of Smash to its knees! The Overarching Master of Smash, MASTER HAND!

Where one stray member of its clan runs wild, comes a potential gold mine to dig up a win! The Miniature Mindless Marauder, LEMMING!!!

And now: for our bonus winners to round out this entry!

By taking up the blade, he steels himself against the forces of darkness that cross his path! The Dragon Warrior, ADOL CHRISTIN!!!

Reporting in per the Galactic Federation's command, she's ready to deliver justice against all who defy her! The Galactic Federation's best ranked pilot, JODY SUMMER!

What do you get when you put an Elusive chameleon, a hyperactive bee, and a skilled crocodile in one Detective agency? A team ready to deliver some fresh chaos on their case! The best trio of the Chaotix Detective Agency, TEAM CHAOTIX!!!

Where many warriors prevailed with using a single sword, one duelist topples the rest! The Crimson Fencer, NAVARRE!!!

And finally, you know the term "Anyone can join the battle?" With these avatars, that rings true even now! And your imagination is your greatest weapon! The Warriors of Many Faces, THE MII FIGHTERS!!!

And there you have it! Brawl is officially done and done! And we have quite a lineup of talent this time around!

But, with Smash 4 on the horizon, who will move on to one of the biggest fights yet? Only one way to find out.

Stay tuned for the next elimination vote. Where 18 more Fighters sadly have to bite the dust.

u/TheSmashShane — 5 days ago

What if Super Smash Bros Brawl was Quadrupled? (Community Vote: Round 7)

We're nearing the home stretch on this entry! And the lineup's only looking stronger every day! And this lucky quintet shouldn't be any different! Let's meet our lucky winners today!

In first place:

Her precision with the blade is as swift as the sky! The Blazing Whirlwind, LYN!!!

Tied for second place:

Who's that girl next door, living in a haunted Mansion? You should know her name or she'll cast a spell over you! The mischievous, Magical Witch, ASHLEY!!!

When grief is a strong tool, his rage burns even brighter against the gods! The God of War himself, KRATOS!!!

In third Place:

It's no use trying to defy fate! The Psychic Hedgehog from the future: SILVER THE HEDGEHOG!

And in fourth place:

Given a chance to prove his worth, he won't stop until he beats the Reaper at his own game! The Quiet Psychic, NEKU SAKURABA!!!!

17 slots remain! Who else will join the game? We'll just have to wait and see who's deemed worthy to become the best! LET'S GO!!!

Rule 1: No downvoting other people's picks! This is an open space to express who want to show some love for their favorite candidates!

Rule 1.5: Adding to this rule, always treat others with respect! This is a safe space to encourage innovation! And I want to maintain a fun space for us to play in!

Rule 2: Video Game Characters only! No 4th party picks allowed!

Rule 2.5: While I want to keep things semi-realistic, I encourage you guys to think outside the box! I'm not solely looking for fan favorites. We've seen a few unexpected entries in the past, so don't be afraid to throw in someone you think would contribute to the game the best.

Rule 3: This title released in January 31st, 2008. But since we had a previous tie-in fighter before, I'll be extending an olive branch to stretch the date to July 10th, 2010. So Fighters like Shulk and Micaiah are allowed to participate here. And DS reps are also allowed to join up too!

Rule 4: 3rd party characters are allowed! As long as they have a solid history with Nintendo.

Rule 4.5: The same can apply to certain Microsoft and Sony reps. (EG, Master Chief and Kratos.) As long as they've made an appearance in some form, they're allowed. But I do want to keep this semi-realistic. Anyone who HASN'T gotten a proper debut on a certain console, they're out. (If they've been shown in IPs like Fortnite or Fall Guys, I'll allow it.)

Rule 5: In the event of a tie, any Fighters who have the same amount of votes will be added into the roster!

Rule 6: You're more than welcome to submit more than one candidate. But to keep everything organized, please put them in one comment at a time. That way they'll have a better shot at getting in!

Rule 6.5: If a character cut from Melee is suggested, they won't be counted. (EX: Birdo, Amy Rose, etc) Since I'm following the formula used for the original games, I want to hold a seperate vote when the 4th game rolls around. So keep an eye out for that! If they're suggested here, then that would defeat the purpose of that vote.

Rule 7: If a fighter's been suggested more than once, then their votes will be added to the first comment!

Rule 8: That should be about everything you need to know for this project. Best of luck to you all! And have fun!

u/TheSmashShane — 6 days ago

What if Super Smash Bros Brawl was Quadrupled? (Community Voting) (Round 6)

Sorry to keep y'all waiting! I've been a bit busy for the past few days tackling a few other projects. But now that I've got some time, we are back with a new round! 8 more winners have entered the fray! And we've got some pretty interesting choices this time! Let's meet our winners!

Tied for first:

One Jester may be a dream come true, but this one may be everyone's worst nightmare! Wizeman's right hand nightmaren: REALA!!!

TIME TO ROCK AND ROLL DUDES!!!! Contra's greatest guerrilla gunner, BILL RIZER!!!

In second place:

He's plugged in and ready to go! There's no task too impossible to handle with this robot! The Miniature Mechanical Robot Helper: CHIBI ROBO!!!!

Tied for 3rd:

Your honor, I must testify that this lawyer is more than capable of holding his own in a fight! The Ace Attorney himself, PHOENIX WRIGHT!!!

With ambitions to become the best Magician of her caliber, she's ready to pop her enemies bubble when she can! Arle Nadja's best friend and Trusted Magical Companion, AMITIE!

And tied for 4th:

This boxer has the guts to take down whoever stands in his way! Literally and metaphorically! The Tropical Chief from the South Pacific: KING HIPPO!

When one renowned warrior of the Stars wasn't enough, comes another to follow in her footsteps! The Elite Spartan of Halo, MASTER CHIEF!

And finally, if you want to avoid this bird's Wrath, you'd better get the flock out of his path! The short tempered leader of the Angry Birds, RED!!!!

And with that, we are down to 22! Who else will join the ranks on this lineup? We'll have to see where this game takes us!

Let's do this!

Rule 1: No downvoting other people's picks! This is an open space to express who want to show some love for their favorite candidates!

Rule 1.5: Adding to this rule, always treat others with respect! This is a safe space to encourage innovation! And I want to maintain a fun space for us to play in!

Rule 2: Video Game Characters only! No 4th party picks allowed!

Rule 2.5: While I want to keep things semi-realistic, I encourage you guys to think outside the box! I'm not solely looking for fan favorites. We've seen a few unexpected entries in the past, so don't be afraid to throw in someone you think would contribute to the game the best.

Rule 3: This title released in January 31st, 2008. But since we had a previous tie-in fighter before, I'll be extending an olive branch to stretch the date to July 10th, 2010. So Fighters like Shulk and Micaiah are allowed to participate here. And DS reps are also allowed to join up too!

Rule 4: 3rd party characters are allowed! As long as they have a solid history with Nintendo.

Rule 5: In the event of a tie, any Fighters who have the same amount of votes will be added into the roster!

Rule 6: You're more than welcome to submit more than one candidate. But to keep everything organized, please put them in one comment at a time. That way they'll have a better shot at getting in!

Rule 6.5: If a character cut from Melee is suggested, they won't be counted. (EX: Birdo, Amy Rose, etc) Since I'm following the formula used for the original games, I want to hold a separate vote when the 4th game rolls around. So keep an eye out for that! If they're suggested here, then that would defeat the purpose of that vote.

Rule 7: If a fighter's been suggested more than once, then their votes will be added to the first comment!

Rule 8: That should be about everything you need to know for this project. Best of luck to you all! And have fun!

u/TheSmashShane — 10 days ago

What if Super Smash Bros Brawl was quadrupled?(Community Vote) (Round 5)

Another round is done and dusted! Who are our newfound winners joining this roster? Let's see who we got!

​

In first place:

​

She's exercised a lot before coming here, and now she's about to exercise all her might for a victory! The Yoga Warrior herself: WII FIT TRAINER!

​

Tied for second:

​

Descending from the stars comes another brave Galactic crusader! The Sentient Spacecraft: TWINBEE!!!

​

Charged up for battle, he's ready to roll! The newest fighter model of Custom Robo: RAY MK III!!!!

​

And tied for third:

​

He's ruled from the shadows, but is stepping into the light for the first time! The Shadow King of the Twilight Realm: ZANT!

​

He's determined to guide the world to a better future however he can! The Chosen Wielder of the Monado: SHULK!!!

​

Watch your step, or he just might dig your grave a bit early! The Drilling Destroyer: DIG DUG! A.K.A. TAIZO HORI!

​

And finally, the root of all Piranha Plants has been planted, and has now bloomed into someone more powerful! The Mutant Piranha Plant of all Piranha Plants, PETEY PIRANHA!!!!

​

And there you have it! Another round of players has been unveiled!

​

But wait, there's more!

​

Here come five new challengers!!!

​

​

Once the best student of Balamb's Garden graduated to a top fighter of his own caliber! The Merciless Mercenary: SQUALL LEONHART!!!

​

Like a Phoenix rising from the ashes, she'll set the competition aflame! The Princess of the Sol Dimension: BLAZE!!!!

​

Burdened by his father's endless cruelty to mankind, he sets off to break the cycle of his constant torment! Dracula's prince of the Night, ALUCARD!!!!

​

She's danced through the danger, and got her wish! To be a fighter for Smash! The Half Genie Hero, SHANTAE!!!

​

No matter how farfetched it looks, he'll reach out to the truth, the only way he knows how! Yasogami's Ace sleuth and bearer of the wildcard ability: YU NARUKAMI!!!

​

​

BOOM! I figured some of these guys were coming a little bit, so I thought I'd give y'all a few freebies!

​

And with that, only 30 slots remain! Who's next in this lineup? Let's see for ourselves!

​

​

GAME ON!

​

​

Rule 1: No downvoting other people's picks! This is an open space to express who want to show some love for their favorite candidates!

​

​

​

Rule 1.5: Adding to this rule, always treat others with respect! This is a safe space to encourage innovation! And I want to maintain a fun space for us to play in!

​

​

Rule 2: Video Game Characters only! No 4th party picks allowed!

​

​

Rule 2.5: While I want to keep things semi-realistic, I encourage you guys to think outside the box! I'm not solely looking for fan favorites. We've seen a few unexpected entries in the past, so don't be afraid to throw in someone you think would contribute to the game the best.

​

​

Rule 3: This title released in January 31st, 2008. But since we had a previous tie-in fighter before, I'll be extending an olive branch to stretch the date to July 10th, 2010. So Fighters like Shulk and Micaiah are allowed to participate here. And DS reps are also allowed to join up too!

​

​

Rule 4: 3rd party characters are allowed! As long as they have a solid history with Nintendo.

​

​

​

Rule 5: In the event of a tie, any Fighters who have the same amount of votes will be added into the roster!

​

​

Rule 6: You're more than welcome to submit more than one candidate. But to keep everything organized, please put them in one comment at a time. That way they'll have a better shot at getting in!

​

​

Rule 6.5: If a character cut from Melee is suggested, they won't be counted. (EX: Birdo, Amy Rose, etc) Since I'm following the formula used for the original games, I want to hold a seperate vote when the 4th game rolls around. So keep an eye out for that! If they're suggested here, then that would defeat the purpose of that vote.

​

​

Rule 7: If a fighter's been suggested more than once, then their votes will be added to the first comment!

​

​

​

Rule 8: That should be about everything you need to know for this project. Best of luck to you all! And have fun!

u/TheSmashShane — 14 days ago

What if Super Smash Bros Brawl was Quadrupled? (Community Vote) (Round 3)

The roster continues to show more promising candidates every day! And it seems we've got another set of great players lined up to take their stand in the ring! Let's meet today's new entries!

​

Tied for first:

​

The laws of reality are only a mere theater for him! Can his demented persona conquer all? Dreamland's Chaotic Clown of the Cosmos, MARX!!!

​

Strong as a dragon, and swift as a fighter jet! The Mach Pokemon, GARCHOMP!!!

​

Pioneering the age where women enter the fighting game scene, her grace is as deadly as her strength! The Blue Jade, CHUN LI!!!

​

Two students caught up in a series of mysteries no other Detective could crack! But their sleuthing minds can make some sense out of any situation! The Detective Club's Dynamic Duo, Ayumi Tachibana and Taro Ninten! THE FAMICOM DETECTIVES!

​

In second place:

​

Elusive she may be in Shadow, none can withstand her deadly prowess! The Kunoichi of Destiny, KASUMI!!!

​

In third place:

​

Where two enemies fall, another plans to stomp out the competition! Bowser's most trusted foot soldier, GOOMBA!!!

​

And tied for fourth:

​

She's hunted many legendary treasures in her time, but none are as legendary as this! The Legendary Tomb Raider herself, LARA CROFT!

​

Where a kingdom's Shrouded in darkness, one mage seeks to restore the light! The Silver Haired Maiden, MICAIAH!!!!

​

And finally, Adorable they may look on the surface, their skills tell a clearer story! The Innocent rabbit and her trusted Chao, CREAM AND CHEESE!

​

We've got another Ensemble of insane talent lined up so far! But who will join our trusted newcomers? Only one way to find out!

​

LET'S GO!!!!

​

​

Rule 1: No downvoting other people's picks! This is an open space to express who want to show some love for their favorite candidates!

​

​

Rule 1.5: Adding to this rule, always treat others with respect! This is a safe space to encourage innovation! And I want to maintain a fun space for us to play in!

​

​

Rule 2: Video Game Characters only! No 4th party picks allowed!

​

​

Rule 2.5: While I want to keep things semi-realistic, I encourage you guys to think outside the box! I'm not solely looking for fan favorites. We've seen a few unexpected entries in the past, so don't be afraid to throw in someone you think would contribute to the game the best.

​

​

Rule 3: This title released in January 31st, 2008. But since we had a previous tie-in fighter before, I'll be extending an olive branch to stretch the date to July 10th, 2010. So Fighters like Shulk and Micaiah are allowed to participate here. And DS reps are also allowed to join up too!

​

​

Rule 4: 3rd party characters are allowed! As long as they have a solid history with Nintendo.

​

​

Rule 5: In the event of a tie, any Fighters who have the same amount of votes will be added into the roster!

​

​

Rule 6: You're more than welcome to submit more than one candidate. But to keep everything organized, please put them in one comment at a time. That way they'll have a better shot at getting in!

​

​

Rule 6.5: If a character cut from Melee is suggested, they won't be counted. (EX: Birdo, Amy Rose, etc) Since I'm following the formula used for the original games, I want to hold a seperate vote when the 4th game rolls around. So keep an eye out for that! If they're suggested here, then that would defeat the purpose of that vote.

​

​

Rule 7: If a fighter's been suggested more than once, then their votes will be added to the first comment!

​

​

Rule 8: That should be about everything you need to know for this project. Best of luck to you all! And have fun!

u/TheSmashShane — 15 days ago

What if Super Smash Bros Brawl was Quadrupled? (Community Voting) (Round 2)

We're already off to a pretty strong start on this entry! And Crash managed to spin back to the game! Sorry again for forgetting him the first time!

​

At any rate, we've got six winners to get through this time! Let's meet our first new additions to the cast!

​

In first place:

​

Once a majestic ruler of another dimension, Cursed to be an Imp by the demon king! The Twilight Princess, MIDNA!!!

​

In second place:

​

Centuries after his demise, his powers carries on in the heart of another! Dracula's Reborn Incarnation, SOMA CRUZ!!!

​

​

In third place:

​

Beyond the stars, she watches over every galaxy with the utmost diligence! The Princess of the Cosmos with her fellow star, ROSALINA AND LUMA!!!

​

And tied for fourth:

​

Even one hot headed athlete can be born from greatness! The Ace Pitcher of StarTropics: MIKE JONES!!!

​

​

SURF'S UP DK DUDES!!! The Fun and Cool Kong of the DK Crew: FUNKY KONG!

​

They've come to our world seeking domination, but maybe this tournament can provide them the window they need! The otherworldly invaders themselves, THE SPACE INVADERS!!!

​

And there you have it! The first set of newcomers have joined the battle! But who will be our next lucky winners? Only one way to find out!

​

GAME ON!

​

​

Rule 1: No downvoting other people's picks! This is an open space to express who want to show some love for their favorite candidates!

​

​

Rule 1.5: Adding to this rule, always treat others with respect! This is a safe space to encourage innovation! And I want to maintain a fun space for us to play in!

​

​

Rule 2: Video Game Characters only! No 4th party picks allowed!

​

​

Rule 2.5: While I want to keep things semi-realistic, I encourage you guys to think outside the box! I'm not solely looking for fan favorites. We've seen a few unexpected entries in the past, so don't be afraid to throw in someone you think would contribute to the game the best.

​

​

Rule 3: This title released in January 31st, 2008. But since we had a previous tie-in fighter before, I'll be extending an olive branch to stretch the date to July 10th, 2010. So Fighters like Shulk and Micaiah are allowed to participate here. And DS reps are also allowed to join up too!

​

​

Rule 4: 3rd party characters are allowed! As long as they have a solid history with Nintendo.

​

​

Rule 5: In the event of a tie, any Fighters who have the same amount of votes will be added into the roster!

​

​

Rule 6: You're more than welcome to submit more than one candidate. But to keep everything organized, please put them in one comment at a time. That way they'll have a better shot at getting in!

​

​

Rule 7: If a fighter's been suggested more than once, then their votes will be added to the first comment!

​

​

Rule 8: That should be about everything you need to know for this project. Best of luck to you all! And have fun!

u/TheSmashShane — 17 days ago

What if Super Smash Bros Brawl was quadrupled? (Community Voting) (Round 1) (4 winners!)

And now, We've arrived at one of the more popular titles so far! Welcome to Super Smash Bros Brawl! 84 fighters have returned for yet another round! This is where the project starts to pick up steam! This roster has officially jumped to a whopping 156 Fighters!

​

The rules of the game remain the same! And to keep things more organized, I'm sticking with four winners for every round. The tied vote rule still stands! Anyone who's tied up with someone with the same amount of votes will also be added!

​

We've got a whopping 65 slots up for grabs! So this is anyone's game! Oh, And for those that were cut here, I won't accept votes to bring them back. Otherwise the vote won't count.

​

Good luck and have fun!

​

Rule 1: No downvoting other people's picks! This is an open space to express who want to show some love for their favorite candidates!

​

Rule 1.5: Adding to this rule, always treat others with respect! This is a safe space to encourage innovation! And I want to maintain a fun space for us to play in!

​

Rule 2: Video Game Characters only! No 4th party picks allowed!

​

Rule 2.5: While I want to keep things semi-realistic, I encourage you guys to think outside the box! I'm not solely looking for fan favorites. We've seen a few unexpected entries in the past, so don't be afraid to throw in someone you think would contribute to the game the best.

​

Rule 3: This title released in January 31st, 2008. But since we had a previous tie-in fighter before, I'll be extending an olive branch to stretch the date to July 10th, 2010. So Fighters like Shulk and Micaiah are allowed to participate here. And DS reps are also allowed to join up too!

​

Rule 4: 3rd party characters are allowed! As long as they have a solid history with Nintendo.

​

Rule 5: In the event of a tie, any Fighters who have the same amount of votes will be added into the roster!

​

Rule 6: You're more than welcome to submit more than one candidate. But to keep everything organized, please put them in one comment at a time. That way they'll have a better shot at getting in!

​

Rule 7: If a fighter's been suggested more than once, then their votes will be added to the first comment!

​

Rule 8: That should be about everything you need to know for this project. Best of luck to you all! And have fun!

Edit: A couple of people noticed Crash was missing. That error was on me. I'll get him back in on the next result!

u/TheSmashShane — 18 days ago

Super Smash Bros Melee: Quadrupled Roster (Cut characters

And so, we have our cut characters from Melee decided. Amy, Birdo, Jack Frost, Nino and by a coin toss, Piranha Plant have all been eliminated!

​

Which means our 84 survivors will go on to battle the Subspace Army in Brawl! But who will join our crew down the line? Only one way to tell for certain!

​

And don't worry, anyone cut here will have a chance to come back for Smash 4.

​

Dr. Mario, Mewtwo, Lucas and Roy were originally cut from the games before coming back. So, alongside them, we'll have 12 more Fighters following in their footsteps! So keep an eye out for the seperate votes when they come out!

​

Speaking of Brawl: We have ten slots open thanks to some of our early entries!

​

Meta Knight

​

Pit

​

Wario

​

Snake

​

Sonic

​

Charizard (Squirtle and Ivysaur will team up with them thanks to Pokemon Trainer)

​

Olimar

​

Diddy Kong

​

King Dedede

​

Wolf

​

So be on the lookout for the next roster! Until then, This is a wrap on Melee! Thanks again for playing this game!

​

​

u/TheSmashShane — 19 days ago

Super Smash Bros Melee: Quadrupled Roster (Elimination Vote: Final Round)

And another set falls.

​

This time, we have to say goodbye to Pocky and Rocky, Vectorman, Banjo/Kazooie, Joanna, and Ryota.

​

We're one step closer to Brawl, but five more will sadly be sidelined with everyone else. Who's in and who's out? Let's find out for ourselves.

​

As always, The five players with the highest amount of votes will be cut from the competition.

u/TheSmashShane — 19 days ago

Super Smash Bros Melee: Quadrupled Roster (Elimination Vote: Round 2)

Well, upon documenting the first few votes, It's obvious we have a few glaring losers today. If you're wondering why I'm posting this one so soon, since it's an elimination vote, the window's a bit shorter than before. And the responses are fairly quick, hence why I chopped down the cutoff window in some points.

​

But in any case, here's our first unfortunate losers who'll be sidelined from Brawl.

​

Donphan, Conker, Rutger, Dry Bones and Ebisumaru.

​

Who will our next quintet of unfortunate souls be? Only one way to tell for certain!

​

Remember, the five highest votes will determine who our losers are.

u/TheSmashShane — 19 days ago

Super Smash Bros Melee: Quadrupled Roster (Elimination Vote) (Round 1)

With Brawl around the corner, the lineup's about to get even more expansive. However, this will mean we will have to say goodbye to a few players on this entry. So sadly, we have to bid a temporary farewell to Mewtwo, Dr. Mario, Pichu, Young Link and Roy. And especially since we still got Mewtwo introduced, but lost him in Brawl, this does mean certain players from the N64 roster are on the chopping block. But on the bright side, they won't stay away forever! There is the opportunity to vote for who you want to bring back in the 4th game.

​

So for this round, I want you to cast your vote into who you want to eliminate. The five players with the highest votes counted will sadly be eliminated.

​

And anyone introduced in Brawl are safe by default. Just about anyone featured in the original games are safe. So you can't vote for any of them, otherwise it won't count!

​

The remaining 84 fighters shown will go onto Brawl! 84 slots, but 20 will be going home. Who will it be? Only one way to find out!

u/TheSmashShane — 20 days ago