u/TheSothoryosWolf

TGC and Emma ironically are at their best when they're doing the opposite of what the writers have done

TGC's Aegon is ridiculously charming and sympathetic. He plays the character with a level of emotional vulnerability and charisma that it's almost a crime. We don't see more of the character as the reluctant, but determined claimant. Out of all of season 3 he only got collectively close to 40 minutes out of eight episodes. Despite trying to make him seem like a villain in the first two seasons, even the episodes with the ridiculous bastard baby fight club and servant assault subplots that went nowhere, Aegon never fails to be endearing, likable, and he plays a tragic protagonist so damn well to the point that when they're trying to villainize him, it just feels out of place. There's so much to explore with the character yet after three seasons, I still feel like we've gotten the bare minimum of Aegon which is a shame because TGC plays the character so well.

On the flipside, Emma is fucking phenomenal when they are allowed to play Rhaenyra as manipulative, ruthless, and outwardly entitled. Rhaenyra at the end of S3 had imo Emma's best acting all season that felt like it belonged with the character. I wish we got to see more of this all the way back in season one. I wish we got this from the second the time started post Milly. For the longest time ever since Emma took over I've personally had trouble connecting the younger version of Rhaenyra with the older, it was like the character had some form of factory reset but the S3 finale felt like a natural progression of what felt like Rhaenyra always should have been as Emma. It feels misogynistic and sexist that instead of being allowed to be the strikingly bold and and hot blooded Rhaenyra George wrote down originally in the Princess and the queen, it took three seasons just to finally get what we should have been relatively from the beginning.

I don't trust the show to stick the landing, but if there's one thing, I am looking forward to it's being able to see TGC and Emma finally act together in the same room interact with each other.

u/TheSothoryosWolf — 2 days ago

House Hightower and the Targtowers are so interesting to me

I've never been a big fan of house Targaryen. I don't hate them, but I find most of them rather boring. It's why when initially fire and blood was released I really wasn't too concerned to read it but I find the Tatgtowers conceptually so interesting, and by extension I find house Hightower incredibly interesting.

Even within the show, whenever someone from house Hightower comes on screen or I see the Targtowers I'm always compelled to pay attention and see where their story is going to go. I'm even more excited to read the winds of winter and see the role house Hightower plays in it and I was excited to see the house mentioned in a knight of the seven kingdoms.

u/TheSothoryosWolf — 2 days ago

I'm disappointed Sara Snow didn't exist in the show

I don't care about Jace/Sara shippers but out of all the random things the show has that didn't exist in the book or was only rumored from mushroom to exist (for TG slander of course) - it would've been interesting to see Sara Snow in the show, especially for developing Jace as a character.

Not in a shipping way and I would be fine if the two never had any romantic connection, not like it matters since Baela moved on before his body was even cold, but showing Jace that it would've been possible to for him to be acknowledged as a bastard and still have a life, have his own identity and most importantly, not be insecure about the circumstances of his birth.

It would also help setup his later resentment at Rhaenyra STILL lying about him being a bastard, even though it was obvious to everyone, including himself. As it stands the North is just a random field trip for Jace where he learns nothing, doesn't grow, and faces no challenges.

u/TheSothoryosWolf — 3 days ago

I hate Daemon and his kids

I hate how Daemon has valyrian steel plot armor throughout the war.

I hate that SOMEHOW Baela survives her fight with Aegon without any injuries while he's crippled AGAIN and Sunfyre is critically wounded while her sister gets the special pink dragon that turns out to be the last rideable dragon

I hate that SOMEHOW Viserys II survives a situation he absolutely should have been killed and even gets to be king eventually like his brother while Jaehaera is brutally murdered.

I hate that somehow even Nettles survives and is potentially living with Daemon because they never found his body after his epic final battle where he kills Aemond, while Daeron gets the most anti-climactic death, but he has to be sure to be dead, explicitly.

I hate when Aegon's forces die they stay dead, but the Riverlands keep respawning anytime the greens wipe them out.

I hate how the dance of the dragons is considered a tragedy where everyone suffers, there's consequences for every action and everyone's children die horrible deaths...except for Daemon and his kids who seem immune to every single rule

reddit.com
u/TheSothoryosWolf — 5 days ago

Do you think HBO will try to capitalize on Aegon's rising popularity?

I remember when even saying that you were a fan of Aegon would get you called every horrific name in the book but now it seems like even the most casual fan loves the character now.

I'm curious if HBO we'll try to capitalize on this even if it's merely insisting that Aegon becomes a bigger part of the marketing and more screen time. Maybe even a POV episode

u/TheSothoryosWolf — 6 days ago

House Velaryon makes no sense and has no agency of their own

None of these characters act out of their own self interest. Every bit of dialogue they say is either contradictory or meaningless.

Corlys: rightfully is angry about Alyn and Addam refusing to be legitimized, it's clear there's no way to do it through Rhaenyra. There's not a single reason for him to still stay loyal if he wants to protect his own family and make sure they can prosper. What does he do? Refuses to switch sides even under torture. The only reason he still loyal is because the story needs him to be loyal. Not because his character would be. They've also have him randomly captured and now without a finger.

Alyn: his literal only loyalty is to his blood, he's denied the chance to be a legitimized, isn't getting paid, and he and his brother are essentially being used as slaves. But once again, undying loyalty to the queen who literally will not lift a finger for him. He literally has no personality. A plank of wood.

Baela: this character makes absolutely no sense. Jace hasn't even been dead for that long and she's already starting a relationship with Alyn, which mind you got zero set up or development. Addam was who I thought they were going with, but I guess that's the one thing in the book they do care about. She's another one that doesn't have any personality to speak of.

Addam: another character with no agency above this one I actually feel bad for. I don't really understand what was the point of making him have a seemingly romantic moment with Baela just to have her rejected him for his brother. With how much the show still has to cover and so many main plots, not getting covered, seems like a waste of time.

Rhaena: I don't think anyone needs to have this redundant and humiliating arc reiterated. Nettles and Rhaena deserve better than a butcher.

The velaryons we never the most compelling characters in the book imo, especially Daenaera Velaryon who materializes out of thin air after the poor Jaehaera Targaryen was randomly murdered (Rip the entire point of Aegon III and Jaehaera being the only survivors of the rival claimants... at least until somehow viserys II returns). But the shell makes these characters frustrating to watch.

None of them have any agency, half of them don't have a personality, and all of them seem to just exist to be Rhaenyra's cannon fodder but the story can't think of any reason to justify their alliance beyond "their loyal" despite the Corlys being even more prideful and ambitious than Otto ever was.

u/TheSothoryosWolf — 11 days ago

Saw this edit and wish even more we got the Targtowers together

(Wish the edit had Helaena in it tho)

u/TheSothoryosWolf — 12 days ago

Less people would be bored with Rhaenyra if the writers just embraced the Maegor with teats/Cersei with a dragon narrative

Rhaenyra is not, and never will be Daenerys. She's not trying to break the wheel. The more the writers keep pushing this narrative the more everyone is bored with the character. I've seen people who have been team black fans since day one jumping ship because they are absolutely bored with the whining, the crying, and the ineffectual writing of Rhaenyra.

It's a shame because Emma would definitely nail Maegor with teats. I wish the writers would let them do it. I wish the writers would lean more into the fact that it's not Alicent who is like Cersei, its Rhaenyra. Book Rhaenyra it is so much like a precursor to Cersei and there's so much more you can do with that.

Instead, they keep trying to force this weird overly sympathetic, never had fault narrative that makes the character look unintentionally incompetent and boring. I'm bored whenever Rhaenyra on screen and I feel bad at this point for Emma working with absolutely nothing but staled bread

u/TheSothoryosWolf — 12 days ago

Aegon and his boy

I saw this edit on TikTok and it made me happy. The silver hair, the golden scales. As it should be.

u/TheSothoryosWolf — 1 month ago

Hotd disappoint me, but not because it's not accurate, but because it's inferior

The OG Game of Thrones was far from a faithful adaptation, even in the early seasons, but I still loved it. George even thought lots of the changes elevated his own source material.

Honestly, I could live with house of the dragon not being completely accurate. Even the best adaptations change things. My issue is that House of the Dragon doesn't elevate the social material at all.

Even changes that have potential end of just being squandered. I have no problem with the black faction being more sympathetic, but it comes at the cost of their complexity and by the verification of the green faction. The show tries so hard to invoke the Daenerys/war of the five kings era of Game of Thrones into their faction that it just comes off as forced and even boring at times. Little effort goes into exploring these characters by their own merits, but instead endless time is dedicated to showing how much better they are than the green faction or how they are really sympathetic, and anything negatively said about them in the social material was either propaganda or misunderstanding. The black faction were not the Starks of the dance of the Dragon, if anything they had more Lannister during the war of the five Kings in them than anything and that's what made them interesting. They were constantly clawing at each other while fighting their enemies, everyone had their ambitions and secrets with each other.

I have no problem with the green infection having darker sides, but it comes at the cost of their endearing, sympathetic, and literal coordination as a faction to the point that they aren't even a faction anymore. so much time is spent sexually humiliating them, making them seem incompetent, hypocrites, making them fight each other or just embarrassingly discredit them. Not one man can have honor, not one woman can have agency, and any suffering they go through has to be completely forgotten about or only shown momentarily if it can't be utilized to verify another one of their members. They are not the learners during the war of the five gangs. They are a mixture of Stannis and even Starks. Stannis because they're fighting for a traditional right regardless of if it's unpopular and Starks because they were a united front. Who genuinely did care about each other had never turned against one another. Unlike the black fashion that was always a powder keg.

And I'm not saying that the show had to or even consider my interpretation of the source material as how it should have gone. My interpretation means nothing. What I am saying is that when you deviate from source material, you have to ensure what you are replacing it with is better. Not dumber, worse, or even a story breaking contrivance that you need to spend an entire season fixing.

It's all the problems of late stage Game of Thrones with none of the earlier seasons and character development/growth that made people endure those later seasons.

No, I don't think Rheanys only being in kings landing to make her dragon kill a bunch of innocent common people and roar at the green faction is a better alternative than the coronation of Aegon AND Helaena then flying their dragons together

I don't think giving Rhaena a completely different story and erasing Nettles for the sake of Daemon and Rheanyra's relationship makes any sense

I don't think erasing Maelor for 2 seasons and making the murder of Jaehaerys to everyone, but his father makes any sense.

Nothing they've done with Alicent or Rheanyra is better, they had somewhere around the 8 to 10 year age gap, they were on good terms for most of it too until the succession crisis started to become more evident.

I could ramble on endlessly about how all these changes don't work but my bigger problem is that they're just not better. They don't elevate the story they bring it down. That's the real issue I have.

reddit.com
u/TheSothoryosWolf — 1 month ago

I wish Tom had creative input on HOTD

I wish Tom got writers and directors that deserved him because he elevates Aegon in ways Mark Addy elevated Bobby B from book to screen

u/TheSothoryosWolf — 1 month ago

Rewatching Ep 3 of hotd S4 really revels how HBO likely regrets S2 even if the writing hasn't gotten better

Before he says anything, I'm not defending the writing at all. Far from it. I'm just noticing how subtly the show is trying to backtrack on almost everything it did.

Alicent, even if she is still lobotomized from the last season, is at least by design from the writers, if not the presentation due to them being incapable of having good execution, most of the time, is more reluctant to give up her sons. Rhaenyra even commenting that Alicent is "still trying to save Aegon's life"

Not once was that ever the case in the last season.

Likewise Alicent comments how absurd it is for Rhaenyra to make a condition that the only way for Helaena and herself to go free is for her to wish death on Aemond, and Alicent also reinforcing the fact that Rhaenyra killed her father.

We also have Daemon directly realizing that it's his fault they can't find the gold and indirectly the show reminds us that it it was Daemon's fault All the rat catchers are gone because of his little skiing with blood and cheese.

We also have that Lord reminding Rhaenyra that the only reason the people of Kings Landing even starved was because of her.

Corlys calling all her children bastards and finally standing on business.

And even the highs septon getting in a couple good shots.

Also Ormund being the best hairstylist in Westeros was a supplied that was kind of silly but also it was hilarious watching Daemon and Rhaenyra get played.

We also have Ulf and Hugh getting even more reasons to be betray Rhaenyra.

None of these things means the show is redeemed, but you can see the redirection from S2. Ep 1 and ep 2 of S3 were obvious leftovers of the last season and I think that's why you see a different treatment come s3.

I don't see this as redemption, but I do find it to be an interesting course correction and I'm curious to see if the rest of the season will continue this.

But maybe I'm just reaching. I'm sure I will be told as so in the comments if I am.

Edit:

As pointed out: I also kind of forgot Maelor now will exist, for however long that will be

Oh and Daemon and Helaena bolts seem to have completely spaced on the prophecy. Daemon is back to being power hungry conquer everything...Helaena wants...chickens. Guess the hound is warging into her

reddit.com
u/TheSothoryosWolf — 1 month ago

Where is Tyland?

For those who know the source material, he was supposed to be in Kings Landing when Rhaenyra took it but three episodes and he's still MIA. Are they still going to do what they did to him in the book? How and why is he even going to go back to Kings Landing at this point knowing it's fully compromised? Is he going to meet up with Aegon? Was he taken out of Kings Landing by the writers because they realize there was no way they could spin Rhaenyra doing what she did to him as a good thing?

u/TheSothoryosWolf — 1 month ago