I (28F) tested positive for an STI and don’t know whether I can trust the guy (28M) I’ve been seeing for 4 months
I (28F) have been seeing a guy (28M) for about 4 months, and we recently became exclusive. Everything has been great and I genuinely had no reason not to trust him until this happened.
I recently tested positive for an STI.
Before we met, he was single and has always been open with me about having slept with other people. Not an unreasonable amount, but enough to get an STI. I had only been sleeping with the same person for the previous couple of years.
I started having symptoms pretty early into seeing him. About a month later, he voluntarily got an STI screening because we were considering becoming exclusive eventually. His test was negative and I saw the actual results. He had the basic urine test (I didn’t even know you could do oral ones - basically I’m saying he could have had it in his throat and not known or tested positive).
Now, months later, I’ve tested positive. When I told him, he immediately went to get tested again, agreed to show me his results, and has repeatedly told me he hasn’t slept with anyone else. Before this, he’s never given me a reason to think he’s dishonest. We’re waiting on his results now but they won’t help me much as we’ve been sleeping together for 4 months and could have easily passed it all over each other for a while considering my early symptom.
The possibility I can’t get out of my head is that his earlier test really was negative, he slept with someone afterward while we were exclusive, caught something and gave it to me. There are also explanations where the infection was already present earlier (like bleeding) and unfortunately I can’t determine when I acquired it.
My options are either to believe that he unknowingly had it and passed it to me and is telling the truth or is lying and is a terrible person. We only became exclusive recently (3 weeks) and I’ve made it clear if he saw someone else before I would not care in the slightest.
I really like him and want to continue seeing him. He’s treated me the best out of all the guys I’ve ever been with and I really don’t think he would lie. At the same time, I’m scared I’m giving someone the benefit of the doubt when I shouldn’t. This would be a huge thing to lie about and a serious concern. My friends keep suggesting he’s lying, but I seriously
believe him.
How would you approach trust in this situation? Is it reasonable to continue the relationship unless I actually find evidence that he’s lied, or is the uncertainty itself something I should take more seriously?