creatine... smh!!!!
I've been lifting weights seriously for about 7 years. My friends think of me as the "fit one" and will occasionally solicit workout advice from me, which they usually don't take anyway lol but it's all good.
Anyway lately I've had multiple people ask me for advice about starting creatine. These are friends who average <1 day/week at the gym, some who maybe only go 1x/month or whatever. A friend who I know for a fact does 0 resistance training was just texting me a bunch of questions about what type of creatine she should buy, what time of day she should take it, etc. I politely answered her questions and told her what I do. I stopped short of telling her that with her current (lack of) routine, creatine is not going to have much noticeable effect and she should probably start by just making the gym a more regular habit first before she starts tinkering with supplements. That felt kinda rude to say so I left it off but it's the truth, no?
I guess creatine is basically harmless and if you add it to your routine even if you don't do resistance training, it's not going to hurt. And maybe you'll still get some of the cognitive benefits? But I feel like the real answer is, go to the gym and lift weights following some kind of progressive overload routine for like a year first. Once you have some kind of baseline muscle mass and are plateauing, then creatine can become a useful tool for getting more reps or more definition.
I personally do take creatine daily and have the subtle but noticeable results one hopes for. But I lifted weights for probably 5 years without any creatine supplementation before I added it to my diet. So I actually had a baseline that I could compare against. It seems as though some people have it in their heads that creatine is some kind of miracle working fitness substance that's going to take them from 0 to hero and misunderstand what it's actually proven to do. I guess this isn't really a big deal, it's part of the nature of things that the culture cycles through these so-called "fitness hacks" that get really trendy for a while and then fall away. It's just funny/slightly frustrating.
I also think it's funny that the same female friends of mine who are wary of resistance training because they don't want to get bulky are now suddenly interested in creatine. I don't consider myself a truly bulky lass by any means but creatine has definitely helped me grind out more upper body reps and increased the bulk of my shoulders and arms. W in my book, they would probably call that an L though lol