

Should I make the switch?
First Image is the basic template I use for all my video reviews. I like it very much, I'm not planning on changing it.
While browsing Youtube though I've noticed that thumbnails with the outer stroke (is there a specific name for it?) catch my eye many times, so I was wondering:
Would you consider the 2nd design more clickable? It's just a quick mockup for how it would look.
I kinda... don't like it? Except for the 3D effect, that's cool.
But if it makes the thumbnail more clickable I don't really mind