u/VictoryCurious3420

Hey everyone,

I’m currently figuring out my next step and would really appreciate some advice from people who have been through the MBA admission process.

A little about my profile:

• BMS (Finance) from R.A. Podar College, Mumbai
• 2 years of work experience at KPMG in the GRCS department (2024 – July 2026)
• I’m from the NT-B category
• I was originally planning to pursue an MSc, but I’m currently facing some issues with that plan, so I’m considering doing an MBA in India instead.

Since it’s already quite late in the year, I’m wondering if preparing seriously for CAT now would be the best option, or if I should focus entirely on exams like MAH-CET, SNAP, NMAT, XAT, etc.

My main targets would obviously be good Mumbai/India B-schools. I’m particularly interested in JBIMS and SPJIMR, but I’m not really sure.

For people familiar with the admissions process:

1. I realistically target with this profile?
2. Any advice on which exams I should prioritise and how I should approach the next few months?

Would really appreciate honest opinion. Thanks!

Hey everyone,

I recently had my Ireland student visa refused for my MSC , mainly due to concerns regarding finances, SOP/course justification, and ID/documentation.

I have now submitted an appeal, and I’d like to know what you guys think about my chances of getting the decision overturned.

Why I was refused & what I changed:

1. Finances

In my original application, I showed my father as my sponsor:

• Father's ITR: 6 L
• Father's bank balance: 6.5 L
  • Around ₹5 lakh was from liquidation of gold
• LIC surrender value: 4.99 L

For the appeal, I've strengthened the financial side considerably:

• Added my cousin sister as an additional sponsor
• Cousin sister's ITR: 12 l
• Father's current bank balance: 12
  • This includes the earlier 5 l + an additional 6 l from gold liquidation
• My PF: 60k
• My personal bank balance: 88k
• Father's total net worth/assets: approximately 1.65 c

I have also provided the relevant supporting documents and financial summary explaining the sources of funds.

2. SOP / Course justification

The previous SOP apparently did not sufficiently explain how the MSc would provide material benefit to me after returning to India.

For the appeal, I have completely revised the SOP and clearly explained:

• Why I chose my course
• How it connects with my previous education/work experience
• Why NCI's MSc is relevant to my career
• How the course will benefit my career in India
• My plans and career opportunities after returning to India

So I believe the SOP issue has been properly addressed now.

3. ID / Documentation

The refusal also mentioned documentation related to the bank loan.

For the appeal, I have now provided the bank loan statement and the required supporting documentation.

Appeal submission

I couriered the complete appeal package, including:

• FCL, Cover letter, Financial summary, Appeal letter, New/revised SOP, Sponsorship documents, Other supporting documents

The documents reached the embassy office on 10 August, and I'm currently waiting for the decision.

What do you guys think?

Given that I have addressed all three major concerns from the refusal - finances, SOP/course justification, and documentation  do you think there is a reasonable chance that the visa decision could be overturned?

Appeal submitted: 10 August 2026
Current status: Waiting for decision

Would really appreciate opinions from people who have gone through an Ireland student visa appeal, especially if you had a similar situation. 🙏