Competing in the CFP
First, I love the new iteration of the Big XII and the parity in the conference is unreal. The fact Arizona was able to pull off 9 wins this past season shocks me and I definitely think futures are bright for a lot of schools.
I am seeing though a very similar trend perception wise to what the Pac 12 went through. Lots of good teams that beat up on eachother and very little elite teams that have the juice to make a playoff run.
In the entirety of the playoff era, only one Big XII team has won a playoff game (TCU vs Michigan in Jan 2023). This includes multiple appearance by Oklahoma and one by Texas when they were still Big XII members. The playoff record since 2014 is 1-9.
What will it take for the Big XII to start winning playoff games? I would imagine the degree of first round exits surely does not do the perception of the conference by the rest of CFB.