I need to ask because I seem to be the odd one out regarding this
I've seen a lot of posts where people say "just writing lyrics" isn't songwriting...
However, to me it is
Here's why:
To me... syllabic count matters: a good songwriter takes this into account while writing lyrics.
Shifts in verses vs chorus sections and so on... all matter: a songwriter takes all of this into account while writing lyrics....
Math matters: Lyrics without rhythm or a natural cadence typically aren't suited to be songs
So, if you're reading lyrics and you can't hear a silent rhythm then yeah... perhaps it's not songwriting.
But, to me, if you're reading lyrics and you can silently hear where the pauses are, where the breaths sit, where the emotions swells... then it is songwriting at its peak... it is what it's meant to be --> a song in word form.
Lyrics, good lyrics, are the heart and bones waiting for the soul and flesh (the instruments) to be built around them.
Yes, it can go the other way around, and it would seem that that is what most of the industry seems to do now, while also pushing loops...
Yet you see many posts commenting about how music just doesn't hit you anymore... and I personally think that this lack of respect regarding lyrics.... the ideal that writing lyrics isn't a form of songwriting.... is a major part of the problem and I feel like this fact... the way this aspect of writing in music seems to have been lost or forgotten is the exact reason why music feels hollow anymore.
Thoughts?