Aeons and their Counters
So 4.6 brought to light a very popular theory of the fanbase, Aeons and their counters or opposites. Nihilux gave us a start of the full diagram between the Aeons so I just wanted to give my own two cents on what I think each pair of Aeons is.
To note however, being counter to another Aeon is not the same as sharing in their origin. Enigmata arose from Remembrance but Mythus doesn't counter Fuli. Similarly Voracity and Elation, both Oroboros and Aha are connected but again, they don't oppose each other in terms of their Paths, rather their Paths are more similar then different. In anycase, starting with the list.
Confirmed in Story
- Destruction vs Preservation
Stated by Nihilux. Not much room for argument here. Nanook wishes to destroy the universe, Qlipoth wishes to preserve. Not much to comment here except to note that Aeons that oppose each other doesn't need to ascend together. Qlipoth is one of the oldest Aeons while Nanook is the youngest. We should keep this in mind as we go to other pairs where some of the Aeons are currently dead or missing. In anycase as for Destruction and Preservation, pretty simple all and all. Push and Pull for the Mistborn fans out there.
- Erudition vs Enigmata
This is a pairing we knew at the start of the game. Mythus rose to oppose Nous, stating if everything was known their would be no future. Nous wishes to know everything while Mythus makes it so knowledge can be wrong or misleading, allowing their to errors and so Nous's extrapolations to don't set the future of the universe in stone. That is there relationship
- Elation vs Equilibrium
This was newly introduced in 4.6, that Aha's actions are blocked by HooH's intervention. According to Nihilux when Aha says "This game sucks, let's play something else," HooH says, "For every gain, a loss. Fair trade." Aha revels in chaos, while a god of games they aren't against cheating or switching things up. HooH however disagrees, in their goal to bring everything to zero-sum, every action comes with reaction, their cannot be anything given for free. Thus does HooH oppose Aha in their constant revelry in always having fun.
Personal theorized pairings
- Hunt vs Abundance
Now this one is pretty much already in the game. Just didn't mention it abive as Nihilux didn't bring them up. Honestly the logic makes sense. Abundance creates overpopulation through immortality while Hunt culls the numbers through death to bring it back to balance. It is a metaphor for an ecosystem scaled to the universe. I should note that this logic for them does actually make it apply to other pairings as well like Voracity vs Abundance, Hunt vs Propagation, Voracity vs Hunt and so on. Lot of these are actually quite valid reads as well but given the sheer antagonism seen in the game about Lan and Yaoshi i thought I keep it simple and keep the pair as is for now.
- Beauty vs Nihility
To me, Beauty and Nihility are the most like opposites. While Nihility does share thematic connections to Elation in both believe nothing matters with different responses, no Path better refutes the statement of nothing having meaning then the Beauty which believes everything in the universe has meaning. That literally is what Beauty is, us putting values on everything we observe. So yeah I think comparing IX and Idrila makes the most sense out of all the options.
- Trailblaze vs Harmony
Trailblaze is a Path of individuality, everyone walking their own road while Harmony is a Path of assimilation, of all become one voice. At least this is the logic Asat Pramad uses in-story where he says Trailblaze and Harmony counteract each other, thus allowing our Stellaron to not spiral out of control. Note Trailblaze I often see paired up with Finality and I do agree with much of theories surrounding it but I feel Finality has a much better pair which I'll mention next so I'll leave off with Akivili and Xipe facing each other.
- Finality vs Remembrance
So Finality and Remembrance. You may be asking why but to me it makes the most sense out of all the pairings. Think of it like this, both Fuli and Terminus ascend at the end of time and travel backwards chronologically yes? What makes them different then? Its because they travel back in time for different reasons. Fuli travels back to recall the whole history of the universe so that they make recreate it all anew, perfectly replicated to all they can remember. Finality travels back as a warning, foretelling doom and sorrow is coming. Why? Because they wish to change their fate. Terminus wants the future to be changed, so that whatever end of the universe that created them doesn't come to past. Fuli and Terminus are counters because their goals contradict each other. Fuli wants everything to stay as they remember them so they can recreate it all again while Terminus wants everything to change so that they never come to be. You wouldn't think Finality counters Remembrance but thinking it like this i don't see what other option fits best for them.
- Permanence vs Voracity
Now were reaching the part im not so confident in. Voracity vs Permanence. I do think the Paths share a connection through Luxbane and I very much believe Long was also a Leviathan like Oroboros was but how would the Paths counteract each other? Well currently i know Abundance can counter Voracity as seen by Evanescia vs the Husk, neverstopping growth vs endless hunger. Abundance pairs up so well with Hunt though so I had to ponder. Think of it like this. It is often theorized that Abundance broke off from the Path of Permanence, especially with how both talk about Immortality. Abundance though is immortality of the self while Permanence is the immortality of the species. If Abundance can satisfy Voracity though, can the Permanence? I believe it can. Just comparing the Paths, Voracity is selfish, only wishing to further your own existence and appetite while Permanence is selfless, letting your own body become the food for others if it means they can survive. Its not a perfect one and one but it is the best reasoning i currently got. Again I do think there is a connection there, given how Luxbane is said to target either Path.
- Order vs Propagation
And now the one I have the hardest time explaining. Honestly in terms of Paths. Order makes the most sense to be against Elation as Law vs Chaos. But Nihilux brought HooH as Aha's counter. Maybe you can explain this as becoming the case due to HooH taking up Ena's duties after their fall as mentioned in Swarm Disaster but thats not the argument i am making today. Honestly I do think you can make a case of Order vs Propagation, just looking at the actions of their Aeons and Paths. Order wishes everything to be controlled but not necessarily stagnant. Civilizations will flourish under Ena's hands but also fall. Followers of Order are noted to be famed martyrs with Ena themself said to have purposefully orchestrated their end so that their Path wouldn't be corrupted by the fear brought by Propagation. Turning to Propagation though, its a Path of personal survival. Tayzzyronth ascended from a fear of death and loneliness and Firefly talks about the wish for survival is baked into the DNA of the Path no matter the consequences it brings. Even though many members of the Swarm willfully give their lives if ordered, it doesn't stop to intrinsic instinct to offer it all up for Tayzzyronth. While the Order will see everything rise and fall as is right, Propagation will buck against this, creating chaos in defiance to a definite end. Ena grew to their strongest during the Swarm Disaster so I do think their is a possible pairing with the Paths as opposites, even if it isn't as apparent at first.
In anycase, thats my list. I feel like lots of folks will disagree with it so feel free to come up with your own pairs and listings, I would love to see it. If any of my points you agree with, I would also love to learn why. Thank you for taking the time to listen to me ramble.