Very indecisive about fellowship, any advice is appreciated
I'm sorry, another "should I do fellowship" post, truly looking for honest advice. I am very grateful to anyone who reads and offers their opinion.
I am a CA-2 at a large academic program. We have all ACGME accredited fellowships and some non-ACGME fellowships in-house. I have scored very well on exams, published/presented research, and am overall a good fellowship candidate. Generally interested in academics post-residency, PP not out of the picture though.
Since starting residency, I have wanted to do fellowship. I have been driven by the desire to be an expert in a field and to feel solidified in my career with the mid-level explosion. Currently, I am very stuck. I generally could see myself enjoying parts of every ACGME fellowship, as well as being content without fellowship. I do feel scared for the future of being a generalist, I understand this is highly debated, but I don't want to be stuck in 15 years feeling like I need to find a fellowship when programs are more competitive than ever, and then having to take a step back for a whole year.
One big important part to this all is my desire to return to my hometown. Since leaving for med school 6+ years ago, I have been on a journey of trying to return home and haven't been able to. Currently, only peds and pain fellowships are offered by programs in my hometown. Even one more year of not being able to go home doesn't sit the best with me.
Going to list my feelings on each ACGME fellowship below.
Critical Care: Initially my goal/main interest coming into residency. I love being able to expand my horizon past anesthesia. I feel competent and confident from the skills I obtain while working in the ICU. I just feel like the pay differential upon getting out of fellowship will undoubtedly push me towards working anesthesia after graduation, and I may just end up losing my skills and not practicing CC after all. Only interested in CC if I can pursue split practice between OR and ICU. No fellowship option in my hometown.
Cardiac: I really like cardiac cases. By far the most engaged I have ever been in the OR. I love the active participation in the case with the surgery team. What I don't like are the very early mornings and the supreme effort that every case demands. I'm a bit concerned that the stress/effort will feel burdensome when the pay differential is small. I also like time flexibility. I like to be able to take 2-3 weeks off at a time. I feel like the reduced cardiac pool will squander this chance. Also no fellowship in my hometown.
Peds: I enjoyed peds cases a lot, but I didn't love the tiny babies. I felt almost useless, as my interventions were unlikely to change the tides significantly. Most neonate cases I was just praying nothing went wrong lol. I'm not the best with kids but I didn't feel like it made much of a difference during my peds months. To me, without a pay differential, it doesn't seem like a worthwhile endeavor.
Pain: Pharm is my favorite part of medicine, so I could see myself enjoying pain, especially with new medications and uses of old medications. The procedures are pretty cool overall. I didn't like my clinic time much as a resident, but it's also because it was filled with lots of downtime and I didn't have much decision-making power. Because of my time as a resident, I never really considered pain much. I'm sure as an attending, it would be much different. I like the aspect of leaving the OR for a bit. I would probably still want to do per diem anesthesia, but from what I understand, you generally need to dedicate yourself to pain practice coming out of fellowship in order to make this work.
Feel free to call me out where I'm wrong and provide any opinions or advice. Thank you so much for taking the time to read this.