Better recommendations for stones for my knives?
Read a bunch of discussions on knives sharpening, looking to make some purchases for an essential knife sharpening set to begin routine sharpening knives for use in home kitchen. I have a mixture of knives from Wusthof, a stainless steel Chinese cleaver, and a Miyabi birchwood chef's knife (SG2). I will probably upgrade or add 1-2 knives (probably Japanese knives or harder steel) for use and have no intentions of turning it into a hobby to collect cool knives.
Some questions:
Shapton Pro 1k and 2k - I don't have a stone holder and apparently this includes one. No sink bridge either (the holder and sink bridges tend to be compatible with most stones and aren't specific to a certain brand,?). I heard the Pro 2k "loads up easily" so maybe there are better recommendations for ~2k grit. I see many people recommend 1k and 5k grit stones as essentials, while others say you don't really need more than 2k, especially if your goal is just sharpening and not looking for polish (which I assume is just purely aesthetics). I'm thinking maybe 3k finishing stone so to pair with 1k sharpening stone.
Should I consider soaking stones? I know it provides better feedback at the cost of wearing out quicker and requiring more frequent flattening but I'm not sure what "better feedback" contributes (e.g. just maintaining a consistent angle?) and whether it's only applicable to a beginner. I'm thinking it might be worth dedicated the highest grit stone to be a soaking stone though it seems arbitrary perhaps I should stick to S&G to keep the same sharpening feel (out of curiosity, I wonder if Japanese knife sharpening pros have any particular preference or if this is really a personal choice). Similarly, I'm not sure if there's a particular advantage to sticking with the same brand for the stones in various grits--I don't suspect so but shopping for stones is kind of hard since even advertised grit is not really accurate or comparable between stones/brands.
Would the Atoma 140 be a good choice as both a flattening stone and the sharpening stone to use if a knife ever chips or becomes extremely dull for presumably a quick sharpening before moving to an ~800 grit stone?
Stropping seems worth DIYing--any particular recommendations on the materials and compound (if necessary)?
I also have an F. Dick steel honing rod but because I've waited until now to sharpen, my knives are probably too dull for it to be useful until they are sharpened. I imagine the ideal way to prolong the edge of a blade (i.e. maximize the edge of the blade before it gets removed from proper sharpening sessions with stones) is to first use the rod whenever the feels like it could be sharper until metal fatigue takes over and it can no longer be kept sharp is when you use stones. In this regard honing rods still have its place even in a home kitchen? It makes intuitive sense to use stones as a last resort because it takes off the majority of the metal to keep the blade sharp and it seems both the honing rod and the strop let you maintain a sharp edge before you create a fresh edge. Alternatively the finishing stone could take the place of a honing rod with just a few strokes, albeit perhaps a little more aggressively? Seems like it should also only be used on non-Japanese metal.
Honing rod and strop technically do different things (rods technically sharpen and creates microbevel while stropping realigns the edge and removes micro burrs), but would you use them in same situations (considering both are similar in that they only really work if the knife is already somewhat sharp and won't work if they are dull)? Stropping seems like it works both for maintenance and as a final step after sharpening on stones, whereas honing rods seem exclusively for maintenance? Both don't require more than a couple of passes at the same angle as sharpening? I believe stropping is strictly edge-trailing but there are reasons to use both edge-trailing and edge-leading on a honing rod?
Lastly, how much cheaper is it to purchase these stones in Japan? I came across a post that says you can get a Shapton for $25 in Japan because that's how much they are worth but that post was also 3 years ago (in the US currently it's double that). Wondering if it's worth planning a shopping list for a trip to Japan end of this year or the next (perhaps the popular stones mentioned in Western forums are not necessarily even popular in Japan because they might have better selections and availability).
Feel free to correct or add on to any of the info above. Any other tips are much appreciated--I did as much homework as I could thus far. I don't have a strict budget and wouldn't mind splurging on a Naniwa or two--it's just that I don't know how long these stones realistically last (if it can last a lifetime of use for home knife maintenance I am more inclined to consider them)? I also think I would probably only need 2-3 stones max and a flattening stone.