
Anyone else prefer the natives in RDR1 than in RDR2?
This isn’t meant to be politically charged or anything, it’s just me loving RDR1 and it’s story
I finished RDR2 recently, and while the chapter with the natives was great, it just seems to fall into the same cliche of the poor Indian who just needs a savior. There’s this weird depiction of the natives elves who live in perfect harmony and balance with nature.
RDR1 had a far more refreshing take on them, most of them were people who grew up on reservations and had went to school, they probably had a higher education than the average American. Nastas especially is portrayed as an intelligent and patient person, without being a mystical medicine man.
The game is also one of the few to put the natives in a moral grey, even though their lands were stolen, they’re an organized gang who rally behind a mass murderer.
Also they’re not shown to be helpless, they have hundreds of men, a fortress in the mountains and guns and horses rather than bows and axes.
Rant over, I love RDR1