u/jeremieesekodi

Why Reverend Insanity’s Power System Is Massively Underestimated

Why Reverend Insanity’s Power System Is Massively Underestimated

I don't know why people underestimate the power level of Reverend Insanity so much. Is it because:

It doesn't talk about higher dimensions, or because characters don't casually throw around flashy attacks that destroy everything for no reason?

First of all, the Gu World is extremely vast. Each continent is at least 8 to 10 times the surface area of Earth, and with 5 continents, that would already be around 25.5 billion km². And that's without even using the theory that the Gu World is 50 times larger than Earth.

People say that Gu Masters cannot be compared to characters from other universes because they rely on Dao and Gu. But that's like saying you can't compare the power systems of a universe that uses mana with another that uses ki. The real problem is that many people don't understand what the Dao actually is.

In the xianxia genre, and especially in Reverend Insanity, the Dao (or Dao laws) represents the fundamental laws, essence, and rules governing the universe.

This concept comes directly from real Chinese philosophy, particularly Taoism, where “Dao” literally means “The Way” or “The Path.” In the novel, however, this philosophical concept is materialized in an extremely rigorous form through Dao Marks.

  1. The Materialization of the Dao: Dao Marks

In Reverend Insanity, the Dao is not some invisible abstract force; it is made of physical and measurable fragments called Dao Marks.

Every element, concept, or power possesses its own Dao Marks: Time Path has time Dao marks, Fire Path has fire Dao marks, and so on.

Everything that exists is made from these marks. A rocky mountain is dense with Earth Path Dao marks, while a sacred river is saturated with Water Path Dao marks. In other universes people talk about “concepts,” but then what exactly is the Dao?

In Reverend Insanity, the distinction between a concept and the Dao goes to the very structure of the power system and the construction of the universe itself. The author established a precise top-down logic: a concept is a human abstraction, while the Dao is the physical and fundamental reality of the world.

Here is how they differ and connect:

  1. The Dao is objective, while concepts are subjective

The Dao (and Dao Marks): These are the objective building blocks of reality. Dao marks exist independently of humanity or any form of life. Even if all living beings in the Gu World disappeared tomorrow, the Dao marks of Time, Space, or Fire would still exist and continue governing the universe. The Dao is essentially the physics of that world.

A concept: A concept is the perception, idea, or abstraction created by living beings. It is a mental construct. For example, concepts such as “Justice” or “Regret” begin as human thoughts before eventually becoming linked to the Dao.

The Dao existed first; humans create new Paths through concepts

This is one of the most fascinating parts of the novel: human concepts can force the Dao to reorganize itself and create entirely new Paths.

At the beginning of the world, only natural Paths existed in the form of raw Dao marks: Time, Space, Earth, Water, Fire, etc. Then great geniuses conceptualized new aspects of existence:

Wisdom Path: Created by the Venerable Star Constellation Immortal Venerable. She took the abstract concepts of thought, will, and emotions, theorized them, and transformed them into a cultivation system. The Dao then manifested these ideas as new physical Dao marks: Wisdom Path Dao marks.

Theft Path: Created by Thieving Heaven Demon Venerable. The concept of “stealing” or “taking what belongs to others” is not a natural law; it is a purely social and moral concept. Yet through his genius, he elevated this concept into a universal law, creating Theft Path Dao marks capable of stealing space, time, or even Gu worms.

One day I was debating with a fan of Lord of the Mysteries about Klein versus a Venerable. He argued that Klein could simply make the Venerable stupid. But with Dao marks, the Venerable would naturally possess resistance because stupidity affects the path of thought and mind, meaning there are defensive methods against it.

He replied that Klein controls the concept of stupidity itself, so he would still win.

But if we assume that concepts are merely fragments of the Great Dao, then every Sequence 0 in Lord of the Mysteries would lose authority over their concepts against a Venerable. After all, becoming a Venerable requires supreme attainment in a Path beyond everyone else. And regarding the refinement of Dao marks in the world itself, a Venerable could theoretically do this in any world because Dao marks are essentially the manifested marks of concepts themselves.

u/jeremieesekodi — 15 hours ago

Fate in Shadow Slave.

I do not understand what “fate” really is in Shadow Slave. The author tells us that fate is something absolute that cannot be changed. Fine, let’s accept that, but then:

  1. The Sun God wraps the threads of fate around Noctis and the others to make them immortal and bind them to the imprisonment of the Demon of Hope. Isn’t that literally manipulating fate?

2 )Cassie can see the future, and she arranges events to reach her goals. The Chain Isles and Antarctica are examples of that, and I think anyone with an Aspect related to future visions could do the same. So where is the overwhelming power of fate if people can constantly work around it?

  1. The Vile Thieving Bird steals Sunny’s fate and his True Name. Everyone forgets Sunny, even the Spell itself, but people like Cassie and Weaver already had preparations against that. So fate is not really absolute, but fine, let’s move on. If the bird truly stole Sunny’s fate, then it should have taken Sunny’s place and everything fate had reserved for him. But instead, it only took the shadow bond and escaped the Nightmare because the Spell confused it with Sunny. After that, nothing. Sunny continues collecting Weaves as usual. So this is supposed to be fate in Shadow Slave? In Lord of the Mysteries, if Amon steals someone’s fate, then for the world and for people, he literally becomes that person. But in Shadow Slave, the bird steals Sunny’s fate and only takes his shadow bond? Why did it not take his Aspect too, since the Aspect is also connected to the shadow bond?

4 )The Nine and Weaver—I never understood the connection with fate there. Weaver could have stopped them, and if he had simply let Slayer die… Also, across the six worlds (realms), there was no one besides the Three Seers capable of predicting the future? Even Nether, the Demon of Destiny, saw nothing coming? And this is supposed to prove the power of fate?

I know that “fighting against fate” is a popular theme, but the author should at least come up with a convincing explanation for it.

reddit.com
u/jeremieesekodi — 1 day ago

Fang Yuan Was Never the Worst Monster in Reverend Insanity

I’m probably not the only one who noticed that the author made us believe Fang Yuan was the worst human being because of his pursuit of immortality, while Spectral Soul and Giant Sun exist.

One of them is the most murderous Venerable in the world, and Giant Sun basically did the same things as Fang Yuan. He is a Demon Venerable, yet people call him an Immortal Venerable. He created the most terrifying path, the Blood Path — even Soul Path never reached the same level of fear and taboo as Blood Path.

And honestly, I wonder if Giant Sun isn’t actually the greatest genius in the world, because Luck Path alone is already unbelievable. I don’t think any other path defies heaven as much as Luck Path and Blood Path do. Blood Path is extremely easy to use, requiring almost no precious resources… unless you consider your own family precious. On top of that, even Spectral Soul’s Soul Path was never feared as much as Blood Path.

Like Primordial Origin, Giant Sun also created an organization — the second most powerful in the world — with a system unfair toward outsiders. Sometimes I wonder if he killed even more people than Spectral Soul, because creating an entirely new path requires enormous time, research, experiments, and resources.

As for Spectral Soul, it wasn’t even humans trying to stop him — Heaven’s Will itself intervened. He was the most murderous being the Gu world had ever seen, creator of an organization so powerful that Heaven’s Will constantly targeted it, and he almost succeeded in resurrecting completely.

reddit.com
u/jeremieesekodi — 6 days ago

“Sunny and Cassie hate fate and want to destroy it, but I think that for both of them, fate has actually been favorable. And don’t come and say that Cassie lost her sight or that Sunny has the shadow bond or had a difficult childhood. Mordret and Nephis are the ones who could truly say they had a hard childhood. Nephis lost her father and mother, then her clan, and faced assassination attempts. Mordret, on the other hand, was considered a monster by his own father from birth and was sent to live with a madman; when he returned home, they even tried to kill him.

Yet neither of them constantly blames fate or complains about their suffering. But Sunny, every time something goes wrong, it’s ‘fate.’

On the Forgotten Shore, Sunny and Cassie actually benefited from fate by meeting Nephis. Nephis had a much higher chance of surviving the Forgotten Shore alone than Sunny and Cassie did. I don’t think Sunny would have survived there on his own. And the memories Sunny receives are extremely useful for his future adventures. He received two Divine memories as if it were nothing, and even a fragment of a divine realm. I think that fragment will eventually make him superior to others once he becomes Sacred.

Not to mention that he is the heir of Weaver. Even his act of defiance was relatively easy compared to others. Nephis had to regenerate countless times to endure the sun of Godgrave. Mordret had to split his soul into millions of pieces while maintaining his sanity. Nephis, in her first Nightmare, had to burn herself over and over again, which is not something quick or easy. Mordret had to endure his own at just 12 years old. Nephis completed her second Nightmare while still a Sleeper, and Mordret went through his as well.

Meanwhile, Sunny ruined his own plan purely out of hatred—he had the ambition to kill a demon while still an Awakened, and I think he could have succeeded. Even Mordret himself says that every time he tries to accomplish something, something happens to stop him (Sunny, the gates opening, Sunny again, the corrupted kingdom…).

So overall, the people who should truly hate fate are not Sunny and Cassie.

reddit.com
u/jeremieesekodi — 21 days ago