u/kennyPowers6570

Hello all, new to this forum and not a frequent flier on Reddit either. I just got these Tecovas Monterrey penny loafers in goat. These are photos new and right out of the box. They look terrible in my opinion. They look nothing like the photos online. Are these supposed to look like this? The heel looks horrible, the tops and tongue look worn slap out. I’m just confused.

I wanted the Beaufort but it was entirely too long. 5’9 145lb male.

Does the Ashby (left) look too long? Either would be in green but my store only had blue in the Bedale. I don’t like the Ashby needing a cuff to fit my arm length properly, but it would require the cuff for proper length as you can see.

What do you guys think? Please let me know before I make such a big purchase!