u/kid-dynamo-

▲ 0 r/LawPH

Curious Question About Sen. Bato Dela Rosa's Situation. SC did not issue a TRO but the main case itself is not yet resolved. What happens when one party follows through their interpretation of the law but SC later rules their interpretation (and subsequent action) is incorrect

NAL so I want to understand what is going on so far.

Before today, Government kept deferring Bato's arrest citing they wish to "resolve all legal issues" before they make moves. They tried to avoid directly answering the questions pero as I understood it, their stance is that ICC WoA is valid, it is enforceable and therefore the Senator can be arrested.

And when they said "resolve all legal issues" I understood it to be referring to the TRO petition only and not necessarily the "main case", which the SC specifically emphasized in their official statement, is still pending.

So now the TRO is denied, pero ang main case is not yet resolved.

So say the Government believing they are in the right, follows through and arrests Sen. Bato. Will they be violating any laws in doing so?

Say, Bato was arrested, sent to The Hague but the SC ruled that the Government's interpretation of the law was incorrect. Ano ang mga violations na pwede ikaso sa kanila?

And what remedies can Bato (and by extension Duterte) avail gayong nasa The Hague na sila?

reddit.com
u/kid-dynamo- — 1 day ago

Wala Bang Building Layout or Map na pinresent kanina sa Press Con ni Remulla about the Senate Shooting?

I am trying to browse through the video clips of the Presscon about the Senate shooting investigation.

I can't find any clip so far or news article na may napresent na building layout or map identifying the approximate locations where individuals are positioned as the event unfolded.

Kasi mas makakatulong yun to give context and mavisualize yung situation. Maybe it can even give some idea sa possible motivations ng mga involved lalo na yung mga nagpaputok ng baril

youtu.be
u/kid-dynamo- — 2 days ago

Is it possible to pinpoint a specific event or time in history when the US "truly" aspired to become a global superpower?

If I am not mistaken. Manifest Destiny was originally limited to the North American continent. Monroe Doctrine was more concerned about the North and South America. Sure these doctrines eventually morphed into a global hegemonic aspiration but for a time isolationism was kind of a thing in American politics

Some say it's WWII, but I had always thought this is the culmination of that objective which the "seeds" (so to speak) that were planted much much earlier.

Was there some kind of a "turning point" in American society and politics where they began to realize that they don't want to be just "a global player" but become THE global player?

Edit:

To further clarify, there is no question they were starting to be a global power at the turn of the 20th Century but they were one of many at that time. What I meant is when did they start aspiring to rise and become the global power above everyone else.

reddit.com
u/kid-dynamo- — 2 days ago

What if Germany had the manpower and resources to sustain the Eastern Front campaign in WWII? How far must they push USSR to finally break its will?

As we know, Germany simply didn't have enough to sustain its brutal war of attrition with USSR. Not to mention the Soviets were able to keep moving their industries (and population) deeper into Russian territory ensuring their war production kept going.

But say Germany didn't have the resource and manpower limits it had. And they can keep sustaining their campaign.

What could have been the breaking point of the Soviets to finally subjugate them?

A lost strategic territory? A destroyed industrial base? A lost resource basket? Death or capture of a military or political leader?

reddit.com
u/kid-dynamo- — 3 days ago

What could have been the "last straw" or how far must the USSR be pushed to break its will in WWII?

As we all know, Germany ultimately lost because they can't wage a prolonged war of attrition before they broke USSR. Not to mention Soviets kept shifting their industries deeper and deeper into Russian territory which enabled them to outstrip Germany in terms of war production.

But say Germany somehow has the manpower and resources to keep going in the Eastern Front.

Could USSR have theoretically been broken at some point?

What could have been the (or the combination of), territorial, industrial base, resource basket, logistical network loss/losses that becomes the catalyst to break USSR into submission

reddit.com
u/kid-dynamo- — 3 days ago

Conversely, Cayetano can be asked bakit nakatambay pa ang buong mayorya sa Senado kung adjourned na? May hinihintay ba sila????

u/kid-dynamo- — 6 days ago

Bato’s actions to 'harm' Duterte’s interim release bid—expert

For all it's worth, Bato's antics just reinforces the idea that if Duterte is granted interim release. Very likely that he will pull off the same shit his underling is doing right now.

Heck, the very idea that a fugitive can use the SENATE as his refuge being shielded by fellow Senators like Robin further gives validity to the idea that ICC intervention is necessary

abs-cbn.com
u/kid-dynamo- — 7 days ago

What are your thoughts about the VP Impeachment Trial?

Does it still matter given that the current Senate composition points to foregone conclusion? Heck, Senators like Cayetano, Padilla, Imee and Bato aren't even hiding their biases anymore.

But then again, maybe there is a silver lining since even if it's doomed, it will still be used as a platform to bring all the evidences of alleged wrongdoings of the VP and her family to public attention and maybe create an environment similar to what happened to Estrada's impeachment

reddit.com
u/kid-dynamo- — 8 days ago

DDS Can't Catch a Break

I mean damn, talk about a losing streak..

April 22 - AMLC revelations during the House impeachment hearing

April 23 - ICC confirms all charges against Rodrigo Duterte

April 28 - ICC formally moves Duterte Case to Trial Chamber III and names presiding judges

April 29 - NBI confirms authenticity and no alteration of Sara Duterte's meltdown and grave threats video

May 02 - DDS vlogger Jay Sonza arrested

May 04 - House Justice Committee unanimously approves taking the Sara Duterte impeachment for plenary vote

May 05 - DDS aligned media network founder Franco Mabanta arrested

May 05 - Latest Pulse Asia presidential surveys indicate slightly narrowing Sara Duterte leads

May 08 - Duterte ICC defense lawyer Kaufman quits

May 09 - ICC issues arrest warrant against Bato Dela Rosa

Update:

May 09 - Duterte's ICC associate lawyer Dov Jacobs also quits

reddit.com
u/kid-dynamo- — 13 days ago

Pang ilan "L" na to ng DDS?

Talk about a losing streak. All the L's just keep piling up

And diba nasa Netherlands si SWOH din I wonder if she had anything to do with Kaufman's sudden decision

Ano yun binato din yata ng laptop ang mga lawyer ni Tatay Digs? LOL

So now the question is sino ang papalit as Duterte's counsel?

u/kid-dynamo- — 13 days ago

So PGMN claims what happened to their prominent personalities is some form of harassment and they were "Set Up" in an attempt to silence them over the discoveries they made against Romualdez.

However, parang mas dumami ang tanong kesa sa sagot sa ginawa nilang statement

Kung 5 months na ang investigation and ang episode was already filmed weeks ago.

  • How come ngayon lang ito tila pinlanong ipalabas?
  • What was the reason for the weeks of hold up in releasing the episode?

If Romualdez tried to silence them and inunahan sila.

  • How did he (Romualdez) even got to know na the expose is about to be released in the first place?
  • Pano siya nainform (at sino) with absolute certainty to the point that he was compelled to mobilize the NBI para unahan si Mabanta et.al.?

Kung may threat sa lives nila and enemies may have contracted hitmen.

  • Why Romualdez even resort to using the NBI at all since using government assets would appear more irregular
  • He could have just went ahead and gumamit ng anonymous hitmen and the attacks can later be blamed on another party?

Ngayon sinasabi nila na may dead man's switch na sila at irerelease ang video the moment may mangyaring masama sa kanila.

  • Why withhold the video any further? Diba as "investigative journalists" ang primary objective is to expose the truth?
  • Why patuloy na itago pa ang video which is the reason hinaharass sila in the first place?
  • Kind of doesn't make sense since releasing the video will reinforce their narrative na hinaharass sila. Moreso it will vindicate their arrested colleagues, diba?
reddit.com
u/kid-dynamo- — 15 days ago

So now Duterte camp attempts to cherry pick by claiming Mans Carpio's AMLC report was "bloated" due to a glitch in reporting by BPI and that the House panel "hid" this fact to sensationalize the unexplained wealth allegations against sa mag asawa.

  1. First the facts, the BPI clarification about the accounting glitch is correct and AMLC was duly notified of this error to which the latter acknowledged in their report. Source: https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/2216650/over-600-duterte-transactions-worth-p6-7b-flagged-by-amlc
  2. On the claim that there was an attempt to "hide" this information to the public is false since the AMLC Report duly acknowledged this and the report itself is available to the public after it was submitted to the House panel as shown in the above link.

Even if, for the sake of argument, we assume the most straightforward calculation of simply deducting the erroneous amount (2,334,617,151.92) and replace with the corrected value (2,110,714.29).

  1. Man's Carpio is still left with Php. 258.29 Million in total CTR & STR inflows and Php 663.85 Million in overall CTR and STR. Sure that's not in the B's but sure as hell still can't be explained based on his publicly disclosed business dealings.
  2. It still doesn't explain the Php. 343.32 Million total outflows from Carpio's accounts.
  3. Taking the "corrected" amounts at face value. Carpio has a net outflow of Php. 85 Million. So may possibility na may mga pumapasok siyang pera na below ng AMLC threshold to be able to accumulate and park at least 85 million pesos sa mga accounts niya.
  4. It doesn't change the fact that VP Sara, who has the decidedly bigger amount in the report, still has to explain around Php. 3.77 Billion worth of CTR and STR.
  5. Or the fact that there is still a combined Php. 4.43 Billion between the couple that still needs to be explained.

Final note, I noticed sa reports that Mans Carpio's counsel appears to have only picked up this angle from social media posts and weeks after the revelations were made at that. Hindi nila agad naisip yun at talagang nag outsource pa ng idea online??? LOL

>“Kung titingnan niyo po ‘yung report, na nakuha rin namin sa social media*, kung bubusisiin niyo po ‘yung report na ‘yun, meron po do’n nakalagay sa bandang dulo na may P2 billion do’n na sinabi ng BPI [ay] system glitch,” Carpio’s lawyer said.*

u/kid-dynamo- — 17 days ago

Granted it was tried before but was abolished because of low profitability, corruption and further liberalizing public transport. Pero after many decades of letting private operators take a crack at it, tila lumala ang public transport condition sa atin. Mga bulok na sasakyan na pahirapan iphase out, transport unions na palaging may strike, mga driver na walang disiplina and so on.

Maybe it's time to reconsider the idea of setting up government run transport companies. of course lessons from the old failures should be learned.

  • Government brings in new (preferably EV) bus & jeepneys helps the old jeepney phase out program.
  • Introducing EV vehicles promotes less dependence to diesel and gasoline.
  • Hiring drivers and conductors from the private sector lalo yung mga na-phase out na mga binibyahe na sasakyan
  • Since arawan ang sweldo ng mga drivers at conductor less likely sila maging barubal sa kalsada.
  • May alternative ang mga pasahero tuwing maisipang mag transport strike ang mga union.
u/kid-dynamo- — 18 days ago

>“Hindi ko sinasabing walang pagkukulang o pagkakamali si VP Sara, pero sa tingin ko, ayoko maging parte nitong moro-moro na ito na labanan ng mga dinastiya at hindi naman talaga ito sa pagsusulong ng accountability, hindi naman ito sa pagsusulong ng good governance. Ito ay para sa labanan ng mga higante sa pulitika. Pinaghihiwalay ang mga tao,”

Kung kailan nakapagpakita ng mas malakas na ebidensya during hearing saka sasabihin na "moro-moro" lang ang ginawa ng Committee na pinangungunahan ng mga minority no less mga kapartido niya na si Delima at kababayan na si Trillanes na (kapartido din).

Tsk tsk tsk

u/kid-dynamo- — 18 days ago

The video asserts that voting (in an election) is skill, not a mere intuition. At dahil dito sinasabi na katulad ng ibang skills kailangan itong pag aralan at matutunan bago ibigay sa tao ang karapatang bumoto.

u/kid-dynamo- — 18 days ago

Throughout post WWII Europe there were many attempts to push for various "Good" narratives (like the Good German, the Honorable Wehrmacht, the Good Nazi and so on) which were obviously done for as many social and political reasons.

But never heard anything remotely similar done to the SS.

Granted they were the most vile with many atrocities and all. But were there really no examples of one or a couple of individual "Good SS" who questioned their mission or worked within to subvert the organization?

reddit.com
u/kid-dynamo- — 20 days ago

In light of the hearing yesterday about the VP's public threats against the President and other people. The case of the teacher getting arrested for putting a bounty on the President Duterte gets renewed attention.

Ang interesting sa case nato is while binasura ng Korte ang kaso at nakalaya ang akusado, ang rason ng pagkabasura was yung illegal ang manner ng pagkakaaresto niya. Yung action niya mismo ay hindi nalitis.

u/kid-dynamo- — 22 days ago

So Co was detained by Czech authorities because he was using an expired (Philippine) Passport that happens to contain his Schengen Visa when he was crossing into Germany.

Granted the Czech Authorities were not obligated to cooperate with PH due to lacking a "police cooperation agreement", pero bakit siya ni-release moreso mukhang nakapag exit pa siya sa ibang border ng Czech Republic? With an expired Passport?

Anyone have a possible explanation how this was pulled off?

In another news coverage, GMA News reported Co did not have a Portuguese Passport as earlier believed after they checked with the Portuguese Embassy in Prague and did not find any Zaldy Co in their records.

https://youtu.be/wezFvA3E5f8?si=gCgcb90XwPrKqIKc

So nakakatravel ka sa Europe gamit ang expired passport as long as valid ang Schengen Visa mo, ganun?

u/kid-dynamo- — 24 days ago

At the 30:00 video mark, Karen asks if the Dutertes accumulate so much wealth, then why was it not manifesting as much in terms of physical assets like land, real estate properties, luxury vehicles, etc. and that is on top of their outward display of simple living? To what they are spending it for?

It was a fair question to ask IMO considering mga ibang pulitiko na sangkot sa nakawan ganun ang gawain.

This was when Trillanes touched the angle that Quiboloy and his church are potentially being used as dummy entities and implies that all of Quiboloy and KOJC assets are in fact owned by the Dutertes. Which explains Quiboloy's generousity to the family like always lending private jets, etc.

Not to mention KOJC is not at the same level as, say, the INC and couldn't have possibly accumulate so much assets as they do

u/kid-dynamo- — 24 days ago