Talking about myself as a ex fan
Oh boy. I just want to talk about this to see if anyone relates in ways of being a now ex fan or not. I’ll be talking about very traumatic things that had happened to me and how Melanie’s music helped at the time.
I, like many older fans, basically grew up with Melanie’s music. I related a lot, and I mean a lot to Crybaby. It helped me get through a lot due to how my life was from 2015-2019. I was young when the original allegations were going around. I didn’t even know what it really meant because I was uneducated in that.
Fast forward to release of k-12, I was in a depressed state due to my grandfather passing a week before. He would listen to Melanie with me. So k-12 helped me there, I felt some form of closure with the music. At the time, I was still oblivious to the rape allegations. After school was okay, kinda really forgot Melanie up until she blacked out all socials and started with portals.
Portals itself helped me a lot because it was 2023, I was 17 and I had horrible mental health due to an abusive ex boyfriend. Some people mentioned how bad her older songs were that were leaked and I decided to listen to some. Rocking horse, Glue stick and WDBCF hit home because I was (not by choice, never once consented) pregnant from abusive ex. I did not want to keep it. Melanie’s songs helped me with my life. I really felt connected to Rocking Horse because of where I was in life.
Then, once the allegations surfaced again. I really looked into it. I understood what it meant. I understood that the same thing that happened to me happened to someone else by the creator of the music who saved my life. I was distraught. Hell I sound parasocial for typing this. I am going to be honest, I was very biased towards Melanie. I never fully learned to let go because of being biased. I look at my merch collection from years prior and it saddens me. I just can’t let go of it for some reason.
I’ve commented this somewhere but some of my favorite and best artwork is Melanie related and that hits home because my art is my life. I just can’t get rid of them. I’ve learned over the years that it is okay to let go. Bad people do exist and it’s okay to get rid of them. Since then, I’ve let go as much as possible from her music. I’ve never really understood “separate the art from artist” when it comes to something as bad as what she’s done.
I (obviously) no longer support her
Anyways I just idk wanted to type all of this for closure(???) I don’t know sob sobbb