r/melaniemartinezsnark

Consistently throughout the history of this womans career she has not one album to beat her debut. Its embarrassing. And in my honest opinion, Crybaby isnt even that good in the first place 😭😭

in 2025, she stated that m4 and m5 will both be released in 2026, as a double album. however Hades has become a complete flop.

she hasn’t announced m5 yet, what do you think ?

Piggyback is officially on Melanie’s tik tok.

“Personal vent song” my ass. It’s free range when she’s losing attention & interest & needs her fans talking about her again, & she chooses to use her allegations that she was suuuuuuchhh a victim of to do it. The desperation is PATHETIC.

She really seems to be on this “bad press is good press” run. Girl can’t depend on creativity she no longer has, she’s so lazy these days she’s gonna make boring cringy shock value songs like the Vatican, and then bait her fans using the same allegations she’s been avoiding like a coward to get them talking. She’s actually such a loser.

Her fans would always claim it was Timothy who would never let Melanie live this down & wanted attention, yet she’s been quiet this whole era & now Melanie is using something she avoids talking about like a pussy and claims she was the victim of so people can keep talking about her.

Ageplaying fantasy album and SA, oh Melanie that’s all you’ll ever be known for & your legacy & she knows it

(Rant)

Melanie fans have harassed Timothy for how many years while she had not spoken about it for years til almost two years ago. She finally gains courage to speak about it again and they STILL say she’s doing it for clout after she’s gotten nothing good from it. Timothy was so brave after everything horrible that came from it was and she shouldn’t have had to go private again from being harassed by Melanie’s fans. I do think that because Timothy has a bit more support than she did last time Melanie is pissed off. Now her worst written album about how she hates everyone and is the victim didn’t get the attention she wanted, she wants to victim blame Timothy again. I’m pretty sure I saw a post speculating it looked like she was shading Timothy on her recent album. But Piggyback was THE song where Melanie clearly was shaming Timothy and using narcissistic tactics like ”was a good friend and you used that to your advantage“ and “you could never come close cause I, know my destiny“ to throw a tantrum after talking about herself as a child (having no correlation to the subject) and how she cut off people because they “came for blood” to build up her “victim” and relatable image to her fans. Melanie is an egotistical loser who can no longer hide behind her crybaby character because she killed her off. Adding piggyback to tiktok officially is again her being the one “dragging it out” and wanting attention, while Timothy told her story and explains herself insanely clearly. Genuinely disgusting how Melanie and her fans intimidate and shame Timothy into silence and hiding.

My brother is actively listening to portals so loud that I can hear it from the living room. As someone who got in so much trouble for listening to Melanie when I was 15 (he's 14), it gave me such egregious war flashbacks

One of my biggest problems with Melanie fans is that they will continue to hate on Timothy but at the same time say "stop bringing it up! It was all false 🥺" The same people who say that are the same people who make edits of Timothy calling her ugly and a liar. If the fans are gonna continue to support Melanie, they can at least stop making videos dissing Timothy. It's embarrassing. Now that Piggyback is on TikTok I can already tell that fans are gonna make some horrible edits.

https://preview.redd.it/e0rf31b02o2h1.png?width=720&format=png&auto=webp&s=bd22c6b0de7af0d0c209c5377b1dd3ac4b9fbd85

track ratings are a FLOP

Not gonna post it, but I saw a tweet that summarizes what most MM fans believe about her & why they defend her. It’s a very common argument, said in different ways, such as:

“She’s always seemed kind and loving, she doesn’t seem like this person (her victim) claims”
“Just Look at her, how could this angel hurt anyone?”
“Look at what she stands for, no rapist would stand for human rights or call out bad people”
“She’s beautiful no one who looks like this is hurting anyone, it’s jealously”

In arguing this, they forget how often, abusers put on fronts & are able to manipulate others with their charm, looks, & personable traits. It’s actually VERY often used against their victims by them as well. Famous Abusers specifically, will carefully & strategically act calm, speak with sophisticated language that isn’t typical for them ( Because their PR team is helping them make statements) and then use things such as activism or even spiritually to play the role of a righteous & grounded person. Ex. Look at how people like Russel Brand re-branded to Christianity a little bit before he was accused and later, found guilty for sexually assaulting multiple women.

They do this while their victim, usually not a famous person, is branded as crazy, jealous, and looking to lie for emotionally reacting not just to them having a vulnerable moment speaking out about their story, but also their abuser now calling them a liar, their fans calling them a liar, & using their emotional reactions (normal when talking about RAPE.) & genuine statements against them.

By genuine statements, I mean victims like Timothy, who did not have a PR team or label to back her up & help her make carefully worded, controlled statements involving public relation professionals whose job it is to control the opinion of the masses by making sure what they hear & read doesn’t offend nor upset them or get them to side with the person/label who’s running their checks.
Melanie’s statements involve a PR team behind her. MOST of what she says isn’t genuine. It’s controlled and approved. Timothy however, her statements & her pain comes from her. Not someone behind her re-writing statements for her or telling her what to say and post.

Anyway, the point is, Melanie’s “kind and loving” persona is crafted & strategic & solely for her brand, & her fans STILL don’t get that. What she posts is controlled. That’s what makes them so easily susceptible to her manipulation. Abusers know how to manipulate and what to do to keep people unsuspecting. They know how to throw their victims emotions & pain back in their face.
Famous abusers benefit and depend on their victims lack of PR training & help from a PR team behind them.

If MM fans seriously believe personality traits make someone not an abuser & isn’t something that can’t be faked or put up for show, then a lot of them will be getting manipulated by & siding with abusers in their own lives or becoming the victims themselves. Rape culture & upholding it is a vicious cycle, they are only creating more victims & putting themselves at risk of becoming one (or being victimized again)

I can't even 😶