For those doing community-led growth - what's still broken about the Reddit/forum "lead finder" tools?
I've cycled through a few of these (the ones that watch subreddits and hand you AI-drafted replies). Every one nailed the demo and then disappointed me on the same three things:
- the drafts sound like a bot, so posting them tanks my karma or gets removed
- it's a firehose of "leads" I never actually reply to
- zero visibility into whether any of it turned into revenue
Curious if that matches your experience or if I'm holding it wrong. What would make one of these actually worth the monthly? Is it better drafts, tighter targeting, ban-safety, or just proof of ROI? Not selling anything - trying to understand if the category is fixable or fundamentally mid.