
IPS screen polarization
For me it seems the main problem causing eye strain / focus issues is the polarizer used for the IPS screen. All screens that are good for my eyes and don't cause any issues are all vertically polarized. I test this by using polarizer sunglasses (they block horizonally polarized light) and if they pass the light looking through them, the screen is emitting vertically polarized light. If I turn the glasses 90°, the go black/dark blue.
Currently I'm using a TUXEDO InfinityBook Pro 14 Gen9 AMD as main driver with a MNE007ZA3-2 panel, vertically polarized, with zero eye issues. My previous laptop, the HP 840 G5 (+ G10 and G11, which I tested) were also vertically polarized.
My smartphone is a Samsung Galaxy S23 (which seems to have the worst PWM), zero issues. AMOLED as OLED is circular polarized.
My 10 year old TV screen is also vertical polarized - zero issues there too.
My previous monitor was a Gigabyte M27UA, zero eye issues, also vertically polarized.
I just went into an electronics store and looked at different monitors and tested each one with my polarizer sunglasses. Here is the result:
- HP 524sh: horizontal
- Samsung S70D: vertical
- HP 527sh: horizontal
- Lenovo L27-45: vertical
- LG 27US550-W: vertical
- Acer QG241Y: vertical
- Dell U2424HE: vertical
- AOC U27G4R: vertical
- Acer XB273UX1: vertical
- AOC Q27G4ZR: vertical
- Acer QG271X1: horizontal
- LG 27G610A-B.AEUQ: vertical
- Asus VG279Q5A: vertical
- LG 27G411A-B.AEU: vertical
- AOC 25G4SRE: vertical
- Acer QG241Y X1: vertical
- Dell P2725QE: horizontal
- HP Omen 27u: horizontal
- Gigabyte M27UA: vertical
- Dell U2725QE: horizontal
- Dell P2720D: horizontal
- Dell G2724D: horizontal
The last three Dells of the list I bought myself and tested them at home, I had to return each one because of eye/focus issues.
Here is a study that shows humans can detect light polarization via Haidinger brushes: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4528539/
Here are some reddit posts related to polarization:
- https://old.reddit.com/r/Monitors/comments/1094cbf/eye_strain_related_to_monitor_polarizer/
- https://old.reddit.com/r/Monitors/comments/wcn57j/eye_strain_with_3_different_monitors/
- https://old.reddit.com/r/monitor/comments/we8t0s/to_everyone_with_eye_strain_solution_wtf/
I'm currently trying to find a new monitor, but because the polarization is not definied anywhere, it's pretty hard. I'm now collecting as much data as possible and by finding out the panel manufacturers, maybe some pattern emerges that helps me find a suitable monitor. My dream monitor would be: 27" 4k, >100 Hz, TCO cerified, vertical polarized.