Just finished Season 19….and wow
I watched Decision Day and the reunion this morning. By the end of Decision Day I was celebrating them going 5-5, and then the reunion was a shocker.
I wasn’t surprised by some of the couples splitting, but Josh/Jalyn, and Derrek/Meghann were surprising for me. I got red flags from Josh from the start and the whole “Burning Man is the most important thing in my life” thing was super weird, but after Decision Day I thought they were good. But HE left HER after she even went to Burning Man with him and enjoyed because she wasn’t passionate enough about it?? Like, dude, you’re 31. There’s got to be more to your life than this, and if there’s not, then you’re not ready for marriage. Jalyn deserved much better.
I was surprised by Derek and Meghann, but I also get it. Miscarriages are rough for couples in traditional situations. Under these circumstances, I could see the effect it could have on their relationship. I was hopeful for them, but I could also see signs that they may not be right for each other from the start, like him not really getting how important her dog was to her and him being so hung up on “3 kids 3 kids 3 kids” even though she already expressed she wanted a kid but she wasn’t sure how many.
Chad and Belynda I wasn’t surprised by because he showed a lot of red flags. I’ve seen a lot of speculation that he may have PTSD from being a combat veteran, so I can certainly extend some sympathy to the man as I can only imagine how difficult that is to deal with, but the outbursts, the drinking, and being divorced 3 times already were not good signs. Then when he talked about how he’s an alpha male and not going to play 2nd fiddle to a dog, that was enough to know that definitely wasn’t going to work. Chad needs some therapy and peace, and I hope he gets it, but they were not a good fit.
I don’t blame Pat for leaving Rhonda. She was a lot from the start, and they just weren’t right for each other in terms of their personalities and needs. Pat seemed like a good guy, but he regularly missed cues from Rhonda that she wanted to share things with him and wanted him to ask follow up questions to show he was engaged, and they just went right over his head. But then she’d dress him down for it. He needed someone less overbearing and demanding, and she needed someone a little more assertive who could handle her big personality and also meet her emotional needs.
Will and Brittany I didn’t think would last after Decision Day, but, man, I was really hopeful. I liked both of them a lot and wanted them to work out. I just think they weren’t right for each other. Brittany was cool and could be a great partner, but she was also very insecure and her communication style didn’t jive with Will’s. She would just kind of speak without thinking when she was upset or worried and he was very thoughtful. I think he wanted to make it work, but just couldn’t meet her needs while having his needs met as well.
TL;DR: Josh was a red flag from the beginning and Jalyn was too good for him. I feel bad for Derrek and Meghann. Chad needs help and isn’t ready for marriage. Pat and Rhonda were not a good fit because of their personalities. Will and Brittany were also just not the right fit.
Overall, I’m kind of disappointed with how this season played out and how short it was, but still better than Chicago and Denver. Everything is still better than Denver.