u/randomahbab

Ozbiljno pitanje, bez provociranja.

Primjećujem da kod nas skoro da nema prostora za ljude koji vjeruju u Islam, ali imaju ozbiljne sumnje prema hadisima i tradicionalnoj ulemi.

Ne pričam o ateizmu ni “liberalizaciji” vjere, nego o ljudima koji smatraju da je Kur’an dovoljan kao izvor vjere i da mnogo toga iz hadiske tradicije nema smisla ni moralno ni racionalno.

Na primjer:
– predaje o pijenju devine mokraće kao lijeka
– 7 datula protiv otrova i sihra
– nasilne i kontradiktorne predaje koje se pripisuju vjeri

Zanima me ima li ovdje još ljudi sa Balkana koji razmišljaju slično ili sam samo upao u internet bubble?

Volio bih čuti mišljenja i iskustva drugih ljudi koji su prošli kroz preispitivanje hadisa i autoriteta.

As far as I can tell, there is almost no space online for Qur’an-alone / Quranist Muslims from the Balkans to connect, discuss Islam openly, and question hadith traditions without instantly being attacked or labeled.

A lot of us believe Islam is true, but we struggle to accept certain narrations attributed to religion centuries after the Qur’an.

Narrations about things like:
– eating 7 dates making you immune to poison and magic
– adult breastfeeding between non-spouses
– drinking camel urine as medicine
– people having their eyes burned out with hot iron
– innocent children supposedly ending up in hell

For many of us, these things simply do not fit with the idea of a complete, rational, and fully detailed revelation.

So we made a Discord server specifically for people from the Balkans who:
• follow the Qur’an alone
• question hadith authority
• want respectful discussion instead of blind sectarianism
• are searching for Islam without clergy culture and fear tactics

The server is new, but the goal is to build an actual Balkan Qur’an-alone community, because many of us spent years thinking we were completely alone in this.

If you know anyone from Bosnia, Serbia, Croatia, Montenegro, Albania, Macedonia, diaspora etc. who might relate to this, please send them the invite.

Discord: https://discord.gg/w98EfnSM35

Peace everyone,

I was wondering if there are any Quran alone muslims here who speak languages from the former Yugoslavia (Bosnian, Serbian, Croatian, etc.)?

Do we have any kind of Discord server, Telegram group, or other community where people from this region connect and discuss Quran-alone perspectives?

If not, would anyone be interested in creating one together? I feel like it could be really valuable to have a space for discussion, support, and exchanging ideas in our native languages.

Let me know if something like this already exists, or if you'd be up for starting one.

Thanks!