Need help making one of the paragraphs in my horror story hit harder.
This is supposed to be the paragraph that the idea of a monster in my book is introduced, if anyone has advice on how to make it better please let me know. (For some context the main characters car broke down and they are walking to the nearest gas station for help)
We had only been walking for about twenty minutes when we heard a weathered old voice call out from behind us “Are you fellas alright? It’s awfully dangerous to be walking out in these woods by yourself.” We turned in unison to see an old station wagon pulling up behind us. The man driving the car appeared to be in his late 60’s or mid 70’s. His long white hair was pulled back tightly into ponytail, while his scruffy face was covered in wrinkles and his chin was populated with intermittent grey stubble. Despite most of his other features being somewhat harsh he had a soft smile and kind eyes. “He reminds me of pap pap” I smiled sadly at the thought. My grandfather had died the previous year while staying at his winter cabin deep in the Cascade Mountains. By then, his dementia had progressed severely, and my grandmother was struggling to care for him alone. They decided to spend a few final months at the old cabin before moving into a retirement home. One morning, my grandmother woke up and found his side of the bed empty. At first, she wasn't alarmed. He often couldn't sleep and would wander around the cabin in the middle of the night, looking for something to occupy himself until sleep took him again. She got out of bed and began searching through all the rooms, expecting to find him sleeping on one of the couches or chairs. After about ten minutes, she realized something was wrong. My grandfather wasn't anywhere inside. She checked the front door. It was unlocked. For a moment, she thought he might have gone outside, but then she noticed something that his coat was still hanging by the door. So were his boots. She swung open the door and saw footprints leading out across the yard and into the woods. Frantically she whipped out her phone and called the police. A heavy snowstorm had passed through the area recently, leaving the road to the cabin buried beneath several feet of snow, meaning, before the police could even reach the property, they had to wait for the road to be plowed. Hours passed before they finally reached the cabin. Upon arrival They immediately began searching the surrounding area. For multiple days, they combed through the trees, calling his name and following every trail they could find, but they found nothing. No clothing. No blood. No sign of an injury. Nothing that could explain where he had gone. Even those tracks that led into the woods abruptly stopped about thirty feet in. Eventually, they concluded that his dementia had caused him to wander outside. Perhaps, in his confusion, he had ignored the freezing temperatures and walked into the woods without realizing what he was doing. My grandmother also told me that she recalled one of the officers asking her if anyone else had been staying up there with them. When she replied that it had only been the two of them, the officer just scratched his head looking confused “Well I’m not sure how to tell you this, but your husband didn’t walk in there alone.” He pointed to the tracks. “You see, there are two sets of footprints. Someone or something was walking with him.”